Official figures and this site's calculations
Latest updates
What changed in the evidence summaries of the register of public money, newest first: the summaries written and revised, the searches of the literature, and the corrected figures.
Summaries published: of 155 lines, holding of 2024 public money. Latest entry: 2026-10-19.
Follow it in a feed reader: Atom feed, the latest 50 entries. Every version is in summaries.csv.
By type
Updates by type
- Summary written (20)
- 2026-10-19 · Old age
- 2026-10-19 · Hospital services
- 2026-10-19 · Outpatient services
- 2026-10-19 · Sickness and disability
- 2026-10-19 · General contribution reductions
- 2026-10-19 · Family and children
- 2026-10-19 · Secondary education
- 2026-10-19 · Transport
- 2026-10-19 · Public debt transactions
- 2026-10-19 · General services
- 2026-10-19 · Unemployment
- 2026-10-19 · Military defence
- 2026-10-19 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs
- 2026-10-19 · Medical products, appliances and equipment
- 2026-10-19 · Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs
- 2026-10-19 · Survivors
- 2026-10-19 · Police services
- 2026-10-19 · Community development
- 2026-10-19 · Pre-primary and primary education
- 2026-10-19 · Social exclusion n.e.c.
- Summary revised (0)
- Summary corrected (1)
- Summary withdrawn (0)
- Literature searched (25)
- 2026-10-19 · Unemployment
- 2026-10-19 · Military defence
- 2026-10-19 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs
- 2026-10-19 · Medical products, appliances and equipment
- 2026-10-19 · Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs
- 2026-10-19 · Pre-primary and primary education
- 2026-10-19 · Survivors
- 2026-10-19 · Social exclusion n.e.c.
- 2026-10-19 · Police services
- 2026-10-19 · Community development
- 2026-10-18 · Old age
- 2026-10-18 · Hospital services
- 2026-10-18 · Outpatient services
- 2026-10-18 · Sickness and disability
- 2026-10-18 · General contribution reductions
- 2026-10-18 · Family and children
- 2026-10-18 · Secondary education
- 2026-10-18 · Transport
- 2026-10-18 · General services
- 2026-10-17 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs
- 2026-10-17 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs
- 2026-10-17 · Fuel and energy
- 2026-10-17 · Communication
- 2026-10-17 · Survivors
- 2026-10-04 · Every line of the register
- Figure updated (0)
- Other correction (50)
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Overseas exemptions (LODEOM)
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Survivors
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · General contribution reductions
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-19 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-18 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-18 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-18 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-17 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
- 2026-10-16 · Does it work?
Newest first
Every update
October 2026
2026-10-19 · Old age · Summary written · Strong
Most studies of the 1993, 2003 and 2010 reforms find that people worked longer; the 2010 reform also raised unemployment and disability. No causal study measures retirees' incomes.
2026-10-19 · Hospital services · Summary written · Moderate
After the 2004 payment reform, heart-attack mortality fell more in private non-profit hospitals facing more competition; a hospital quality bonus and a discharge programme had no significant effect on quality.
2026-10-19 · Outpatient services · Summary written · Moderate
Studies find care use raised by incentives to limit extra fees, zero-cost dentures and outreach, with no significant overall effect of free complementary cover. None measures forgoing care.
2026-10-19 · Sickness and disability · Summary written · Studied, not on its goals
More generous sick pay raised sick days in most private-sector studies; an unpaid first day cut civil servants' short absences. No causal study measures the line's goals.
2026-10-19 · General contribution reductions · Summary written · Moderate
Most studies of the 1990s low-wage cuts find more jobs; the 2003 Fillon reform and the CICE's 2019 conversion into a contribution cut showed no clear effect on employment.
2026-10-19 · Family and children · Summary written · Strong
Studies of the 1994 extension and the 2015 cut of paid parental leave find the first lowered mothers' employment and the second raised it. No causal study measures child poverty.
2026-10-19 · Secondary education · Summary written · Strong
Randomised trials (guidance meetings, boarding places) find gains in grade progression and maths; a study of priority-education zones finds no significant effect on results. Evidence on job entry is limited.
2026-10-19 · Transport · Summary written · Studied, not on its goals
Studies of the Paris RER and of high-speed lines up to 2017 find more jobs and dearer housing where they arrive; none measures the State's goals for this spending.
2026-10-19 · Public debt transactions · Summary written · No policy effect to evaluate
Interest on the public debt pays lenders on bonds and loans already issued; it serves no outcome goal, so there is no policy effect to evaluate.
2026-10-19 · General services · Summary written · No causal study found
No causal study of this line, mostly local authorities' administration, was found . A review without a causal design finds their staff in all functions grew with no new powers transferred .
2026-10-19 · Unemployment · Summary written · Strong
Studies find longer or easier benefits slowed the return to work and the 2019-2021 cuts sped it; the 2021 cut lowered the benefits affected claimants received by about a third.
2026-10-19 · Military defence · Summary written · Studied, not on its goals
Studies of the end of conscription in 1997 find effects on young men's schooling, wages, voting and naturalisation; no causal study measures the armed forces' official goals.
2026-10-19 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs · Summary written · Moderate
Studies find counselling and hiring aids raised employment, sometimes briefly or at other job seekers' expense; training for job seekers did not speed exits from unemployment, with mixed later gains.
2026-10-19 · Medical products, appliances and equipment · Summary written · Limited
Studies of a pilot paying hospital prescribing units part of the savings find it raised biosimilar use, with small savings; none measures the retail generic substitution rate.
2026-10-19 · Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs · Summary written · Very limited
Studies of tax disclosure rules find that stricter documentation cut reported charity deductions in 1983 and that a lighter wealth-tax return lowered reported wealth; none measures diplomacy's goals.
2026-10-19 · General contribution reductions · Summary corrected · Moderate
The 2008-2009 hiring credit was a grant paid by Pôle emploi, not a contribution reduction: its study is counted on general economic and labour affairs; the level is unchanged.
2026-10-19 · Survivors · Summary written · No causal study found
No causal study of survivors' pensions was found . A study without a comparison group computes that the pension largely keeps widows' living standards from plummeting at widowhood .
2026-10-19 · Police services · Summary written · Very limited
Studies of the speed cameras deployed from 2003 find road deaths fell, from national series without a comparison group; a study of a city's cameras finds them marginal against crime.
2026-10-19 · Community development · Summary written · Limited
Studies find urban renewal cut the poorest households' share only where demolition was heaviest and drew better-off buyers; the 2014 priority label drove families from local collèges.
2026-10-19 · Pre-primary and primary education · Summary written · Strong
Studies find smaller classes, including the 2017 halving in priority schools, raised scores, mostly in maths, not always lasting; an extra teacher and a reading programme showed no significant gain.
2026-10-19 · Social exclusion n.e.c. · Summary written · Strong
Studies find the 1989 minimum income lowered some groups' employment, in-work benefits mostly had no significant effect, help with claims raised take-up and the RSA cut young adults' homelessness.
2026-10-19 · Unemployment · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of unemployment benefits published since the search of 4 October 2026, and those the search notes list as unread: the 2019-2021 reform (eligibility, degressivity, daily reference wage, bonus-malus), the 2023 cut in benefit duration, the solidarity allowance (ASS), working while claiming, older job seekers, benefits for founders. In: the HAL API (11 queries, 2025-2026), the Crossref API (8 queries, from 2025), the OpenAlex API (1 query, then refused for the day), Unédic's list of publications (unedic.org, 4 pages), the IPP's site (ipp.eu), the Internet Archive's copies of the Dares publications; the Dares site answered with a captcha, HAL's full texts with a bot check, SSRN with 403. Found: five evaluations of the 2019-2021 reform, coded as rows 371-375 (Dares, Documents d'études n° 273, 280 and 281; Rapport IPP n° 55; Dares, Valorisation de la recherche n° 17); not coded: the evaluation committee's final report (Dares 2025), a review of them; the journal version of row 66 (Economie et Statistique n° 550, 2026); descriptive and qualitative Dares and Unédic studies; nothing on the ASS or the 2023 cut.
2026-10-19 · Military defence · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of French defence spending and its rules since the search of 4 October 2026: base closures and restructurings, defence procurement and R&D, the volunteer military service (SMV), the Journée défense et citoyenneté, the reserve, military pay and recruitment, conscription. In: the HAL API (12 queries), the OpenAlex API (14 queries, then refused for the day), the Crossref API (4 queries), the TEPP site; the HAL archive's documents on the SMV, OpenEdition and the Cour des comptes' search could not be used (bot check, a search that ignores its terms). Found: nothing new to code: another HAL version of row 206; a thesis that names an SMV evaluation without its estimate or design; descriptive studies of the defence restructurings and of the SMV's cohorts; a cross-country study of defence R&D that evaluates no French measure.
2026-10-19 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of the State's labour-market programmes and support to firms published since the search of 4 October 2026: France Travail's services and counselling, training of job seekers, the youth employment contract (CEJ), subsidised contracts, insertion through work (IAE), emplois francs, apprenticeship aid, short-time work, the 2020 state-guaranteed loans (PGE), Bpifrance, export support, enterprise zones. In: the HAL API (13 queries, 2025-2026), the OpenAlex API (9 queries, then refused for the day), the Crossref API (10 queries), the IPP's list of publications (ipp.eu, 8 pages), the strategie-plan.gouv.fr and cae-eco.fr sites, Persée, the arXiv; the Dares site answered with a captcha, vie-publique.fr with a challenge, SSRN, Wiley and Cairn with 403, HAL's full texts with a bot check, and IDEAS' search returned nothing. Found: three studies coded as rows 376-378 (a France Travail randomised trial, arXiv 2026; the 2021 rise in the training allowance, Industrial Relations 2026; subsidised contracts, Economie et Statistique 2015); not coded: two studies of the PGE with self-selected participants or no magnitude, a youth programme the abstract does not name (Filippucci 2025), a regional distance-training scheme with no conclusion on employment (Rapport IPP n° 56), innovation grants and competitiveness clusters (another line), an e-mail trial on platform take-up; descriptive and qualitative studies.
2026-10-19 · Medical products, appliances and equipment · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of the reimbursement of medicines and medical devices published since the search of 4 October 2026, and older ones the search notes lack: generic substitution rules, biosimilar incentives, delisting, price regulation, co-payments on medicines, the reform that made some glasses and hearing aids free, early access and the hospital add-on list. In: the PubMed API (24 queries), the OpenAlex API (29 queries, then refused for the day), the HAL API (17 queries), the Crossref API (12 queries), the Irdes site (its lists of Questions d'économie de la santé and working papers), the Insee site; HAL's file server answered with a bot check, and the Drees and Cour des comptes sites' searches returned no usable results. Found: two studies coded as rows 379 and 380 (a biosimilar gain-sharing pilot, Economie et Statistique 2024; the 2006 delisting of mucolytics, Health Policy 2011); not coded: an Irdes before-and-after study of the same delisting (2007), studies of co-payments on declared behaviour, microsimulations, structural models, multi-country and descriptive studies; nothing causal on generic substitution rules, price regulation, the free glasses and hearing aids or the homeopathy delisting.
2026-10-19 · Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of the executive, Parliament, the tax administration and diplomacy since the search of 4 October 2026: tax audits and enforcement, reminder letters, withholding at source, online filing, the right to make a mistake, the ban on holding several mandates, elected officials' pay, parliamentary staff, embassies and state visits. In: the HAL API (17 queries), the OpenAlex API (18 queries, then refused for the day), the Crossref API (10 queries), the NBER and IDEAS/RePEc pages, the DITP site; Cairn answered with 403, HAL's files with a bot check, and the DITP site's search ignored its terms. Found: one study coded as row 381 (the wealth tax's simplified return, NBER 2023, revised 2026); not coded: a close-election study of mayors holding a département seat and the grants they obtain (Revue économique 2021), a study of state visits pooling France, Germany and the United States (2007), two studies of parliamentary staff and reserves without a retrievable abstract, correlations and before-and-after studies of the cumul des mandats.
2026-10-19 · Pre-primary and primary education · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of nursery and primary school policies (class size and the 2017 halving of early-grade classes in priority education, schooling at two and compulsory schooling at three, extra teachers, reading programmes, priority education, cités éducatives) since 2024, and the IPP's education notes. In: the HAL API (9 queries in French and English, 2024-2026), the OpenAlex API (7 queries, from 2024), the IPP site's search (3 queries); HAL's pdf links answered with a bot check, and education.gouv.fr (DEPP) refused automated access (403). Found: El Bah (2026) on the persistence of the 2017 class halving to sixth-grade entry, coded as study 383; the published version of study 171 (Herbaut, Farges and Giret, Oxford Review of Education 2024), same design; not coded: DEPP descriptive notes on class size, a CAE note on education spending (a review), master's theses and qualitative studies of cités éducatives; study 166's manuscript read in full: not randomised, scored 3.
2026-10-19 · Survivors · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of survivors' pensions (pensions de réversion, their means test and age condition, the widowhood allowance) and of widowhood and living standards since 2024, and the IPP's pension reports. In: the HAL API (3 queries in French and English, 2024-2026), the OpenAlex API (5 queries, from 2023), the IPP site's search; the INED server of the working paper did not answer, so its HAL abstract was read. Found: nothing new to code: an essay on whether pensions should take the couple into account (Aubert and Bonnet, Revue d'économie politique 2026), descriptive studies of widowhood duration (Tréguier, Bonnet and Blanchet, Demography 2025; Bonnet and Tréguier, Population et Sociétés 2025) and legal notes; study 39 is now read on the law's goal of a satisfactory living standard for all retirees.
2026-10-19 · Social exclusion n.e.c. · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of the RSA, the prime d'activité, youth support programmes (Garantie jeunes, CEJ), non-take-up and the effects of minimum income on poverty and homelessness since 2024, and the IPP's reports on them. In: the HAL API (13 queries in French and English, 2024-2026, five on titles), the OpenAlex API (7 queries, from 2024), the IPP site's search (2 queries); HAL's pdf links answered with a bot check. Found: Renou (2026), an ex ante estimate of a 20% rise in the RSA on deprivation, coded as study 384, a simulation; not coded: an experiment on outreach to retired self-employed workers whose outcome is health care use (Augé and Sirven, Health Economics 2026), a model of RSA caseloads in Paris (2025), self-financing tests of prime d'activité reforms (Bierbrauer et al., 2024), gains-to-work and legal analyses, and qualitative studies of the CEJ; three studies recoded from the means-of-existence goal to the integration goal from their own texts (Heim 2024, Heim and Galitzine 2024, Bozio et al. 2026).
2026-10-19 · Police services · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of police and gendarmerie spending (staffing, neighbourhood policing, priority security zones, video surveillance and body-worn cameras, municipal police, speed cameras, rules on the use of force) since 2024. In: the HAL API (9 queries in French and English, 2024-2026); the OpenAlex API answered 8 queries with HTTP 429 (rate limit); the IPP site's search returned nothing on the police; interieur.gouv.fr refused automated access (403), and the full text of the Montpellier video-surveillance thesis is behind HAL's bot check. Found: nothing new to code: SSMSI methodological papers on recorded crime, legal and sociological work on municipal police, body-worn cameras and police-gendarmerie zones, a thesis on crime and platform jobs (not police spending), and an essay on speed enforcement (Carnis 2025); the speed-camera studies were reread from their HAL abstracts: interrupted time series with no comparison group, scored 2.
2026-10-19 · Community development · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of urban policy (priority neighbourhoods and their 2014 redrawing, urban renewal PNRU and NPNRU, emplois francs, educational success programmes, cités éducatives) and of town-centre programmes (Action cœur de ville, Petites villes de demain) since 2024, and the IPP's and France Stratégie's reports. In: the HAL API (9 queries in French and English, 2024-2026), the IPP site's search (2 queries) and the references of the notes found; the OpenAlex API answered with HTTP 429 (rate limit); Légifrance refused the shell (403), so the 2014 law was read through a fetch tool. Found: Garrouste and Lafourcade (Note IPP n° 110, 2024) on the 2014 priority label and school avoidance, coded as study 385; Cusset et al. (France Stratégie, Note d'analyse n° 133, 2024) on fifteen years of the PNRU, coded as study 386; Bressoux et al. (Rapport IPP n° 13, 2016) on the programmes de réussite éducative, coded as study 387; not coded: qualitative studies of cités éducatives and urban renewal, a chapter on Action cœur de ville in the Grand Est (no abstract), a study of mountain farm subsidies (another line).
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
The matched comparison of the communes that entered the ZRR in 2017 now finds, by 2025, private jobs −6.3% (interval −13.5% to +0.8%) and employers −2.5% (−5.8% to +0.8%), where it found −7.4% (−14.5% to −0.4%) and −3.9% (−7.2% to −0.5%): neither interval excludes zero, so the ZRR page says the fall cannot be distinguished from zero, and the evaluations page lists the jobs result among those that cannot be told from zero rather than among those that exclude zero.
2026-10-19 · Overseas exemptions (LODEOM) · Other correction
The overseas exemptions (LODEOM) are coded on the employment goal of the State programme that pays for them, and count again as evaluated under the strict definition: 10 measures, €104.7bn or 5.7% of public money, and 1.5% without the general cuts in employer contributions, against 9, €103.2bn, 5.6% and 1.4% before. The line is rated Very limited, on the limited effects on employment the IGAS-IGF evaluation finds. On the Haut-commissariat's perimeters of aid to companies, the strict share rises from 32.9% to 38.8% for perimeter 1 and from 78.3% to 79.6% for perimeter 2; the share of public money with evidence on impact moves from 68.3% to 68.4%.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Community development line, Garrouste and Lafourcade (2024) on the 2014 priority label is no longer counted on social mix and is scored 3 on the Maryland scale, not 4, and the evaluation of the programmes de réussite éducative (Bressoux et al. 2016) is read as touching the goal of equal access to education, not measuring it. The social-mix goal, and the line, fall from Moderate to Limited.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
The study of the emplois francs by Chareyron, Challe, L'Horty and Petit (2022) is tied to the General economic, commercial and labour affairs line, not Community development, coded on no goal, and scored 2 on the Maryland scale, not 5.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Community development line, four goals the law sets are coded besides the State programme's two: real equal access to education and public services, the social mix of deprived neighbourhoods, the fight against discrimination by place of residence (loi n° 2014-173, art. 1) and the revitalisation of town centres (CCH, art. L303-2). Letrouit (2020) on the PNRU is counted on social mix, in the goal's direction rather than mixed, and the Action cœur de ville study (Lefebvre and Daly, 2026) touches the town-centre goal.
2026-10-19 · Survivors · Other correction
In the register, the Survivors line (GF1003) moves from studied to no causal study found.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Survivors line, a goal the law sets is now coded, a satisfactory living standard for all retirees, and Cimelli (2023), on survivors' pensions and living standards at widowhood, is read as a simulation, not a causal study.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Four design scores on the Social exclusion line are lowered on the Maryland scale: the Garantie jeunes study by Sawadogo and Vilches (2024) and the RMI duration study by Terracol (2009) from 3 to 2, Sicsic (2022) on in-work benefit reforms from 4 to 3, and Heim and Galitzine (2024) on the 2019 prime d'activité from 5 to 2.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Social exclusion line, three studies are moved from the goal of adequate means of existence to the goal of social and professional integration and the incentive to work: Heim (2024) on a support programme for single parents, Heim and Galitzine (2024) and Bozio, Eryzhenskiy, Leroy and Tô (2026) on the 2019 rise in the prime d'activité; the last is read as no detectable effect on employment, not as a gain in purchasing power.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Two design scores on the Pre-primary and primary education line are lowered on the Maryland scale: the 2002-2003 experiment with reduced first-grade classes (Bressoux, Lima and Monseur 2019) from 5 to 3, and the observation of halved REP+ classes (Lima, Bressoux and Dessus 2020) from 4 to 2.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the same line, three studies are read against the goal of pupils' skills: Goux and Maurin (2010) on schooling at two and Goux, Gurgand and Maurin (2017) on a reading programme are coded no significant effect, not mixed; Farges, Herbaut and Giret (2023) on schooling at two is coded in the goal's direction, not mixed.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Pre-primary and primary education line, two reviews of published evaluations (Merle 2022; Bouguen, Grenet and Gurgand 2017) are no longer counted as findings on pupils' mastery of core skills, and the goal is named without its list of indicators.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Three goals are renamed: on Unemployment, « Replacement income for job seekers », without « (insurance and ASS entitlement) »; on Medical products, « Efficiency and medically guided control of spending on medicines »; on Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs, « Fight against tax fraud (P156-1) ».
2026-10-19 · General contribution reductions · Other correction
On the General contribution reductions line, the study of the 2008-2009 small-firm hiring credit (Cahuc, Carcillo and Le Barbanchon, 2019) no longer counts on the employment goal, and the published summary's third finding loses its second clause; the line stays Moderate.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
The study of drugs removed from the hospital add-on list (Rachet-Jacquet, Toulemon and Rochaix, 2021) is tied to Hospital services, not to Medical products; the Medical products line falls from Moderate to Limited.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Two design scores are lowered: on the Unemployment line, Khoury, Brébion and Briole (2019) from 4 to 3; on the Medical products line, Tano et al. (2024) from 2 to 1. Neither changes a level.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
The Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs line now has goals: the objectives of the State programmes that run the tax administration (P156) and diplomacy (P105, P151). The study of the 1983 tightening of the documents needed to claim charitable deductions (Fack and Landais, 2016) counts on the goal of fighting tax fraud; it scores 2 on the design scale, not 4, and is read as a study of more enforcement, not of a cut.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Medical products line, the goal is now named for what the official objective covers, the efficiency and medical control of spending on medicines, with its two indicators for medicines, generic substitution and biosimilar uptake. The two studies of a hospital incentive for biosimilars (Tano et al., 2023 and 2024) now count on it; the study of the 2018 delisting of anti-dementia drugs (Lecerf et al., 2026) is read as a side outcome, as the goal it named belongs to the health division as a whole. The 2024 study of the incentive scores 2 on the design scale, not 5: it compares hospitals without randomisation.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the General economic, commercial and labour affairs line, the six studies of the research tax credit (CIR) and of the CICE no longer count on the goal of effective aid to firms; the working-paper version of the 2009 hiring-credit study and the France Relance committee's review of the apprenticeship aid no longer count as findings. Each study now counts on one goal, so the goal of France Travail's service is read as touched, and the goal for residents of priority neighbourhoods no longer names emplois francs. Four design scores fall from 4 to 3 (two CICE studies, the two versions of the first enterprise-zone evaluation), and Charnoz (2018) is scored 2.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Unemployment line, the State programme's objectives for France Travail's services and for insertion tools (P102-2, P102-3) are now goals of the General economic, commercial and labour affairs line, where that spending is counted, and no longer of this one. The study of the 2014 information letter on benefit extensions (Boutchenik and Lardeux, 2020) is read as touching the replacement-income goal, not measuring it; a new study of the 2021 reform measures the allowance received, so the goal is now measured. Of the design scores checked, Granier and Joutard (1999) falls from 3 to 2 and Khoury (2023) from 4 to 3.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Under the strict definition, a single measure counts as evaluated only when a causal study measures its effect on one of its goals: 9 measures, €103.2bn or 5.6% of public money, and 1.4% without the general cuts in employer contributions, against 13, €111.8bn, 6.1% and 1.9% before. The exemption of employee savings and profit-sharing (120108), the 10% VAT rate on housing works (730213), the 10% rate for restaurants (730221) and the overseas exemptions (LODEOM) are now not yet evaluated. On the Haut-commissariat's perimeters of aid to companies, the strict share falls from 38.8% to 32.9% for perimeter 1 and from 81.6% to 78.3% for perimeter 2.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Three design scores on the Secondary education line are lowered on the Maryland scale: Alet and Bonnal (2011) and Bénabou, Kramarz and Prost (2009) from 4 to 3, and the randomised trial AvenirPro (Cahuc et al. 2024, study 369) from 5 to 4.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Secondary education line, Alet and Bonnal (2011) is no longer counted on the goal of further study or labour-market entry after secondary school, only on competences and diplomas.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
The Cnaf-Drees note on the 50% rise of the allocation de soutien familial in 2022 (register of official evaluations, row 30) is listed as a microsimulation, not as a causal evaluation.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
Elmallakh (2023), on the 2015 means test of family allowances, is read as touching the goal of reconciling work and family life, not as measuring it, and no longer counts as a finding on it; Givord and Marbot (2015), on the 2004 childcare subsidies, is scored 3 on the Maryland scale, not 4.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Family and children line, three studies of the 1994 extension of the paid parental leave (APE) to second children (Piketty 2005, Moschion 2010, Lequien 2012) are now read as against the goal of reconciling work and family life, not in its direction: they find the extension led mothers to stop work and lowered their later wages.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the General contribution reductions line, the study of the 2003 Fillon reform's job flows (Duhautois and Gilles, 2013) now scores 3 on the design scale, not 4: its instruments, the grouping of a sector panel and the lagged reduction, are not a quasi-random source of variation. The two syntheses (Bozio and Wasmer, 2024; L'Horty, Martin and Mayer, 2019) are no longer counted as findings, since they review the studies counted beside them, and the study of the 35-hour package with its aid (Crépon, Leclair and Roux, 2004) is read as touching the goal. With seven findings and none scored 4, the employment goal falls from Strong to Moderate, and so does the line.
2026-10-19 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Outpatient services line, the study of zero-cost dentures (Tubert-Jeannin et al., 2026) now scores 2 on the design scale, not 3: it compares dentures with another kind of care in the same population, and its authors report trends that were not fully parallel before the reform. With four findings scored 3 or more, the goal of equal access to care falls from Strong to Moderate, and so does the line. The goal is renamed "Equal access to care (low out-of-pocket costs)": no study measures the forgoing of care its former name promised.
2026-10-18 · Old age · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of old-age pension rules and reforms published in 2025-2026, after the search of 4 October 2026: the 2023 reform, the old-age minimum (ASPA), combining work and pension, the retirement age, retirees' living standards. In: the HAL API (6 queries, 2025-2026), the OpenAlex API (8 queries, from 2025), the IPP's list of publications (ipp.eu, 6 pages), the Cour des comptes evaluation platform (the page of evaluations.csv row 28); IDEAS/RePEc answered with a bot-traffic notice and no results. Found: nothing new to code: descriptive or case-type studies (Aubert, and Nortier-Ribordy, Économie et statistique 2025; Drees, Études et résultats n° 1369, 2026, on poverty at retirement), a microsimulation (Bozio, Tô and Tréguier 2025) and a 14-country study (Lugova, Belloni and Legendre 2026).
2026-10-18 · Hospital services · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of hospital financing and organisation published in 2025-2026, after the search of 4 October 2026: activity-based tariffs (T2A), emergency departments, ambulatory surgery, the Ségur de la santé, hospital quality. In: the HAL API (6 queries, 2025-2026), the OpenAlex API (6 queries, from 2025), the IPP's list of publications (ipp.eu, 6 pages); the Drees study of evaluations.csv row 27 read in full (drees.solidarites-sante.gouv.fr). Found: nothing new to code: a study of cost variation within the DRG classification without a counterfactual (Milcent, Health Economics Review 2025), a pricing review (Or and Penneau 2025, WHO) and a student report on ambulatory surgery.
2026-10-18 · Outpatient services · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of outpatient care published in 2025-2026, after the search of 4 October 2026: GP and specialist fees and incentives, free or subsidised complementary cover, extra fees (OPTAM), group practices, under-served areas, out-of-pocket reforms. In: the HAL API (7 queries, 2025-2026), the OpenAlex API (7 queries, from 2025), the IPP's list of publications (ipp.eu, 6 pages) and the note and CREST working paper it links. Found: Note IPP n° 118 (Choné and Wilner, November 2025) on the 2017 GP fee rise, coded as row 367; not coded: a stated-preference experiment on task delegation (Combes, Paraponaris and Videau 2025), a thesis without a counterfactual on primary care teams (Angibaud 2025), descriptive and qualitative studies.
2026-10-18 · Sickness and disability · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of sickness and disability benefits published in 2025-2026, after the search of 4 October 2026: sick pay and its waiting days, invalidity pensions, occupational-injury benefits. In: the HAL API (4 queries, 2025-2026), the OpenAlex API (4 queries, from 2025), the IPP's list of publications (ipp.eu, 6 pages). Found: nothing new to code: the 2026 study of the waiting day in local government is already row 5; a descriptive study of invalidity pensions by early-career earnings (Mohammad, Roy, Tô and Tochev, Économie et statistique 2025) and descriptive or legal pieces.
2026-10-18 · General contribution reductions · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of the general reductions of employer contributions published in 2025-2026, after the search of 4 October 2026: the general reduction, the reduced health and family rates, their 2025-2026 reforms. In: the HAL API (5 queries, 2025-2026), the OpenAlex API (5 queries, from 2025), the IPP's list of publications (ipp.eu, 6 pages); the full text of a payroll-tax incidence paper on HAL returned a web page, not the PDF. Found: nothing new to code: an incidence study of six payroll and income tax reforms (Bozio, Breda, Grenet and Guillouzouic, Review of Economic Studies 2025), not of the reductions, judged from its abstract; an OECD working paper on low-wage employment (2025) and a model of the reductions and the minimum wage (Terriau, Albertini and Poirier 2026).
2026-10-18 · Family and children · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of family benefits, parental leave, childcare and child protection since the search of 4 October 2026, and the institutes' reports on them. In: HAL API and OpenAlex, 14 queries in French and English on publications from 2025, and 4 on child protection with no date limit; the IPP site's search; the Drees publication page; ccomptes.fr search returned no results for a query (scripted page). Found: Parler Bambin, Note IPP n° 72 (2021), coded as study 368; the Cnaf-Drees note on the 2022 ASF increase (2025), a microsimulation, which corrects evaluations.csv row 30; no causal study of child protection; nothing new on parental leave or childcare subsidies.
2026-10-18 · Secondary education · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of collège and lycée policies (priority education, class size, vocational lycées, guidance, social mixing, homework help) since the search of 4 October 2026, and the IPP's education reports. In: HAL API and OpenAlex, 12 queries in French and English on publications from 2025; the IPP site's search; education.gouv.fr (DEPP) refused automated access (403). Found: AvenirPro, Note IPP n° 109 (2024), coded as study 369; Azmat, Grenet, Huillery, Souidi and Algan (2026) on the collège social-mixing programme, coded as study 370; study 177's further studies read in its full text, which are still secondary school.
2026-10-18 · Transport · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations of transport spending (high-speed and regional rail, urban public transport and fare-free schemes, roads, cycling, Grand Paris Express, the clean-vehicle bonus) since the search of 4 October 2026. In: HAL API and OpenAlex, 12 queries in French and English on publications from 2024; the IPP site's search. Found: nothing new: descriptive and qualitative work on fare-free transport, a study of open-access competition on the Paris-Lyon high-speed line (a regulation, not public money), and the Clermont fare-free report already coded as study 237.
2026-10-18 · General services · Literature searched
Searched: causal evaluations and official reviews of general administration spending, mostly local authorities' (staff, purchasing, buildings, shared services between communes). In: HAL API and OpenAlex, 10 queries in French and English on publications from 2024; the IPP site's search; ccomptes.fr search returned no results for a query (scripted page), so the Cour's report was found by web search. Found: no causal study; the Cour des comptes's report on local public finances, October 2024, part 2 (evaluations.csv row 55); evaluations.csv row 37, the IGF-IGA review of State support to local investment, concerns grants counted on GF0108, not this line.
2026-10-18 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Outpatient services line, the goal of equal access to care is counted as measured: six studies measure the care used when out-of-pocket costs or barriers fall (free or subsidised complementary cover, incentives to limit extra fees, outreach against non-take-up, zero-cost dentures). The study of take-up of the ACS voucher and the study of midwives' new scope are read as touching the goal; the study of Asalée's diabetes follow-up is counted on the care-pathways goal only. The register also holds a new study, Note IPP n° 118 (2025), on the 2017 rise of the GP consultation fee.
2026-10-18 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the Hospital services line, the goal of improving the quality of hospital care is counted as measured: four studies measure it on hospital patients (heart-attack mortality, a score of process quality indicators, readmissions, a randomised trial of a discharge programme), although none measures its official indicator, healthcare-associated infections. The study of mobile hospital teams in nursing homes is counted on the emergency-department goal only.
2026-10-18 · Does it work? · Other correction
The IPP's report on the clean-vehicle aids, Rapport IPP n° 49 (2024), is now coded from its full text: the bonus-malus lowered the mean CO2 of new cars by 2.7% in 2019 in a model's simulation, and the extension of the prime à la conversion to Crit'Air 3 cars showed no change in scrapping. Being a simulation, it moves from the causal studies, now 342 instead of 343, to the simulations, now 25.
2026-10-17 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs · Literature searched
Searched: the apprenticeship hiring aid, in the IPP's reports for France Stratégie and the France Relance evaluation committee's. In: ipp.eu, the committee's final report (vie-publique.fr). Found: Rapport IPP n° 51 (2024); the committee's final report, volume I (2024).
2026-10-17 · General economic, commercial and labour affairs · Literature searched
Searched: the evaluations the IPP made for France Stratégie and the Haut-commissariat. In: the IPP's list of its work for the Haut-commissariat (ipp.eu), each report in full. Found: Rapport IPP n° 59 (2025) on Territoires zéro chômeur de longue durée.
2026-10-17 · Fuel and energy · Literature searched
Searched: the evaluations the IPP made for France Stratégie and the Haut-commissariat. In: the IPP's list of its work for the Haut-commissariat (ipp.eu), each report in full. Found: Rapport IPP n° 50 (2024) on the decarbonisation aid to industry.
2026-10-17 · Communication · Literature searched
Searched: the evaluations the IPP made for France Stratégie and the Haut-commissariat. In: the IPP's list of its work for the Haut-commissariat (ipp.eu), each report in full. Found: Rapport IPP n° 40 (2023) on the Plan France Très Haut Débit.
2026-10-17 · Survivors · Literature searched
Searched: the evaluations the IPP made for France Stratégie and the Haut-commissariat. In: the IPP's list of its work for the Haut-commissariat (ipp.eu), each report in full. Found: Rapport IPP n° 65 (2026) on reversion rules, a simulation.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
The register now holds the published evaluation of the apprenticeship hiring aid, Rapport IPP n° 51 (2024), with the France Relance evaluation committee's reading of it, both cited first on the apprenticeship page, and four other reports the IPP wrote for France Stratégie and the Haut-commissariat: Territoires zéro chômeur, France Très Haut Débit, the decarbonisation aid to industry and the reversion rules.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
Interest on the public debt, €58.9bn in 2024, is counted as a line with no policy effect to evaluate, apart from the lines where no causal study or review was found, which fall from 13.9% to 10.7% of public money.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
On the French page, the tooltips of the evaluations table and the panels of its studies name their authors and this site's evaluations in French; on both pages, a study listed with "et al." among its authors reads "Payen A et al.", not "Payen A and et al.".
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
The table of impact, leakage and permanence applies one rule to every study: a verdict counts only against a goal of the line, from a causal design; money that reaches people the law does not target, such as landlords under housing benefit, is capture, a leakage, recorded apart from who ends up with the money among those it targets; a study of a cut is marked; and the 23 findings that rest on a model's simulation are ringed and left out of the counts.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
Every panel of a figure this site calculates says “Calculated by this site” beside its status.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
The DSR saving is dated, 2016-2019, scoped to the fraction cible, €324m in 2019, and read beside the rule that a commune balance its operating budget and borrow only to invest.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
The register section says that the line of research and development for the economy may hold the research tax credit, which has causal studies, and that the State's grants to local authorities weigh €0.1m because consolidation removes them.
2026-10-17 · Does it work? · Other correction
The summaries state their rule: a result counts when its 95% interval excludes zero and it passes its design's checks, no gap before the change and a placebo that finds nothing. Two do, the DSR saving and the DETR's first-year jump against communes' own past; the other results that exclude zero are named with the check they fail or lack. The pages had said three results exclude zero, the fall in prices where Pinel closed among them.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The DSR result is said to hold where the grant comes and goes from year to year, and the page says it cannot tell how steady recipients use the grant; the summaries had said the DSR is saved. The DETR design is said to have the power to detect only a leverage of at least about 12, not to detect one of about 12; and the State's objective for the investment grants is quoted in full.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
Of the 155 official goals, a causal study measures 50 and touches 10 more only indirectly; the pages had said 60 were measured.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The register codes each study on the goal it measures, on three levels: measured, touched only indirectly, or not measured. Who ends up with the money, through wages, rents or parents, is recorded as a fact, apart from leakage.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The summaries recounted this site's evaluations as two descriptive changes and the results whose intervals exclude zero, each with its design; they had counted three changes.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The apprenticeship hiring aid for higher-education contracts is said to have lapsed in January and February 2025 and 2026 until the year's finance law and decree; the pages had said it was withdrawn.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The vacancy and zoning pages now open on what each design can tell: vacancy moved by +0.13 per 100 dwellings against the communes taxed since 2013, whose rates rose in 2023, and the zoning estimates run from −1.00 to +0.35 flats per 1,000 inhabitants depending on the estimator. Both had opened on “no fall”.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The 292 communes added to the vacancy tax in 2024 are described as the communes the decree of 25 August 2023 added to the list of tight urban areas of more than 50,000 inhabitants; the page had described them as outside the large urban areas.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
The research tax credit's effect on researchers is now among the results these estimates cannot tell from zero; the summaries had counted it among three changes.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
Public money counts the payable tax credits once, inside spending, where the national accounts record them. The share of public money in single measures with a causal study moved from 6% to 6.1%, and the upper bound for broad lines from 82.2% to 82.3%.
2026-10-16 · Does it work? · Other correction
Since the 2023 pension reform, employment at 60-64 has risen more than at 55-59, so the gap between the two age bands narrowed; the pages said it grew.
2026-10-04 · Every line of the register · Literature searched
Searched: every line, for causal evaluations of its measures and rules. In: the HAL, Crossref, OpenAlex, PubMed and IDEAS/RePEc catalogues of research and publishers' pages, line by line, and a general web search engine until its allowance ran out; some research departments' sites refused automated access, so a study they publish may have been missed (data/literature/gaps). Found: literature/studies.csv.