Register of 2024 public money · GF1004
Family and children
In short. Studies of the 1994 extension and the 2015 cut of paid parental leave find the first lowered mothers' employment and the second raised it. No causal study measures child poverty.
2024
€66.7bn, of public money, line 6 of 155
Strength of evidence
Strong level 4 of 4, on 1 of its 5 goals: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families) · on rules or parts of the line, which have no separate cost
Studies
20 causal studies tied; 13 findings on its goals
Summary
Version 1 · written 19 October 2026 · history
What it is and who gets it
Family benefits and services: family allowances, parental leave pay and childcare support, mostly paid by social security, chiefly its family branch, plus child protection and crèches run by local authorities.
Goals and the evidence on each
- Compensate family costs and help families raise children (limit living-standard gaps by family configuration): touched only, 1 study measures something it depends on
- Help vulnerable families more (living-standard gaps, child poverty, effect of benefits on child poverty, child-support recovery): no causal study found
- Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families): Strong, 13 findings
- Sustainability of the family branch (financial balance, ecological transition, correct payment of benefits): no causal study found
- Better identification of children in danger (P304): no causal study found
What the studies find
Of the 13 findings on its goals: 2 in the goal's direction, 7 mixed, 1 with no significant effect, 3 against it; 3 of them study a cut in the measure.
- Extending paid leave to second children in 1994 led many mothers to stop work (Thomas Piketty, 2005) (quote not yet matched to the source) (Zsuzsanna Makay, 2023) and lowered their later wages (Laurent Lequien, 2012); cutting it by a year in 2015 raised mothers' employment by 20 points in the child's third year (Mathilde Guergoat-Lariviere et al., 2023).
- Higher childcare subsidies under the 2004 PAJE raised paid childcare use and, less, mothers' participation (Pauline Givord and Claire Marbot, 2015); crèche places added under the 2007-2015 plans brought no substantial change in parents' employment and displaced costlier childminders (Pierre Pora, 2020).
- Fathers' full-time leave take-up rose only from 0.5% to 0.8% after 2015 (Helene Perivier and Gregory Verdugo, 2021); in a randomised trial, help with crèche applications raised poorer families' applications but barely their access (Laudine Carbuccia et al., 2025).
What is missing
- No causal study measures family living standards or child poverty, goals the family branch's programme sets (the goals).
- No causal study was found of child protection, the back-to-school allowance, the complément familial or the 2021 longer paternity leave (search of 18 October 2026) (search notes).
Other official evidence, without a causal design
- A microsimulation, not a causal design: Cnaf and Drees estimate the 50% rise in the family support allowance in 2022 lowered single-parent families' poverty rate by 1.5 points (Cnaf-Drees, 2025).
- A review without a causal design: IGF and IGAS find family policies « restent centrées sur la compensation générale du coût de l'enfant » (IGF-IGAS, 2026).
How this summary was made
Literature searched on 18 October 2026: causal evaluations of family benefits, parental leave, childcare and child protection since the search of 4 October 2026, and the institutes' reports on them. Searched: HAL API and OpenAlex, 14 queries in French and English on publications from 2025, and 4 on child protection with no date limit; the IPP site's search; the Drees publication page; ccomptes.fr search returned no results for a query (scripted page). Strength of evidence rated by the rule on the Method page.
- Version 1, 19 October 2026, written · by writer: First version. Latest updates
Under the register's two definitions
Broad definition: a causal study in the line
evaluated
At least one causal study is tied to this line, on all of it or on one of its rules; the line then counts in full, so this is an upper bound.
Strict definition: a single measure with its own cost and study
not yet evaluated
A spending category: the register holds no separate cost for the measures inside it, so none of its money counts under this definition.
20 causal studies are tied to this line, the latest from 2025. The share of public money under each definition is on the evaluations page.
Against the Haut-commissariat's perimeters of aid to companies:
- not placed: the report lists no measure of this line
The literature
The studies that touch this line
Philippe Chone et al. (2004). Offre de travail feminine et garde des jeunes enfants. Economie & prevision, no. 162, pp. 23-50.
- Design, as recorded: Structural discrete-choice model of paid childcare use and mothers' labour supply (part-time, 80%, full-time), with policy simulation
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: effect « Le temps partiel féminin est fortement sensible aux incitations financières de l'APE »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- a simulation, not counted
- a study of a cut
Thomas Piketty (2005). L'impact de l'allocation parentale d'education sur l'activite feminine et la fecondite en France, 1982-2002. Les Cahiers de l'INED (Histoires de familles, histoires familiales), Ined Editions.
- Design, as recorded: Reform-based evaluation of the 1994 APE extension to second children using two independent sources (Enquetes Emploi 1982-2002, Enquete Famille 1999); estimator detail not stated in retrieved abstract
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: adverse « ne se seraient pas arrêtées de travailler à la naissance de leur 2e enfant en l'absence de la réforme de 1994 »
- Leakage: leakage found « entre 100 000 et 150 000 mères de 2 enfants (sur environ 300 000 allocataires de l'APE de rang 2 au 31 décembre 1997, dont 220 000 à plein taux) »
- Permanence: not informed
Julie Moschion (2010). Reconciling Work and Family Life: The Effect of the French Paid Parental Leave. Annals of Economics and Statistics, no. 99/100, p. 217.
- Design, as recorded: Comparison of the causal effect of having more than two children on mothers' participation before vs after the July 1994 APE extension (reform-based DiD)
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: adverse « having more than two children no longer has a negative effect on the participation probability of mothers »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
Laurent Lequien (2012). The Impact of Parental Leave Duration on Later Wages. Annals of Economics and Statistics, no. 107-108.
- Design, as recorded: DiD using 1994 APE extension to 2nd-born children as exogenous shock to parental leave duration
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: adverse « this reform did induce many mothers to withdraw from the labor market in the 3 years following the birth »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: lasts « interruption duration would have a negative causal impact on wages after the return to work »
Laudine Carbuccia et al. (2025). A randomised controlled trial on the effect of administrative burden and information costs on social inequalities in early childcare access in France. OSF preprint.
- Design, as recorded: Multi-arm RCT (information-only vs information plus personalised administrative support)
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « the information-only treatment had minimal impact, while adding personalised support to alleviate administrative burdens significantly bridged the SES and migration gaps in early childcare applications »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
Nelly Elmallakh (2023). Fertility and Labor Supply Responses to Child Allowances: The Introduction of Means-Tested Benefits in France. Demography, 60(5), pp. 1493-1522.
- Design, as recorded: RDD at the income thresholds of the means-tested family allowance modulation
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: touched « receiving half the amount of the allowances or none leads to an increase in both male and female labor supply through an increase in overtime work »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not applicable
- a goal only touched, not counted
- a study of a cut
Guillaume Allegre et al. (2015). Child care and labour market participation in France: do monetary incentives matter?. Annals of Economics and Statistics, no. 117-118.
- Design, as recorded: Structural model jointly estimating mothers' participation and childcare type, with simulated benefits and taxes for each participation choice
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: effect « We show that monetary incentives do play a role. »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- a simulation, not counted
Ariane Pailhe et al. (2024). Can Daddies Learn to Care for Babies? The Effect of A Short Paternity Leave on the Division of Childcare and Housework. Population Research and Policy Review, 43(3) (working-paper version: 'Can daddies learn how to change nappies? Evidence from a short paternity leave policy', HAL 2018).
- Design, as recorded: Quasi-experiment from survey timing: fathers who had already taken paternity leave vs fathers intending to but not yet on leave at the Elfe two-month interview
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: mixed « Le fait de prendre un congé de paternité conduit à un partage plus équitable de plusieurs tâches parentales. Il n'a qu'un effet marginal sur le partage des activités ménagères. »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- another outcome, not counted
Lawrence M. Berger et al. (2021). The Impact of Center-Based Childcare Attendance on Early Child Development: Evidence From the French Elfe Cohort. Demography, 58(2), pp. 419-450.
- Design, as recorded: IV using birth quarter and local creche supply as instruments for creche attendance at age 1
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: mixed « crèche attendance has a positive impact on language skills, no impact on motor skills, and a negative impact on behavior »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- another outcome, not counted
Pierre Pora (2020). Keep Working and Spend Less? Collective Childcare and Parental Earnings in France. EconomiX working paper 2020-29 (also Insee working paper on HAL).
- Design, as recorded: Staggered-adoption design exploiting the timing of subsidised childcare expansions across municipalities
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: no significant effect « These plans did not lead to any substantial change in parents' labor outcomes or in paid parental leave take-up. »
- Leakage: leakage found « these collective childcare expansions crowded out more costly formal childcare solutions »
- Permanence: not informed
Jerome Poulain et al. (2024). Evaluation de l'impact du dispositif Fais-moi une place sur les trajectoires professionnelles. Rapport IPP no. 52.
- Design, as recorded: DiD: mothers residing in EPT Plaine Commune vs other EPTs of Seine-Saint-Denis, before/after May 2018 launch; plus matched event study of beneficiaries
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « Aucun effet du programme n'est détecté sur l'accès à la formation »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
Guy Laroque and Bernard Salanie (2014). Identifying the Response of Fertility to Financial Incentives. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 29(2).
- Design, as recorded: Structural discrete-choice model of female participation and fertility, identified by wage-induced variation in benefits and tax credits among comparable households
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: effect « financial incentives have had a significant effect on fertility decisions in France »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not applicable
- a simulation, not counted
- another outcome, not counted
Thomas Piketty (1998). L'impact des incitations financieres au travail sur les comportements individuels : une estimation pour le cas francais. Economie & prevision, no. 132-133.
- Design, as recorded: DiD across population groups (number of children, family structure) exposed differently to 1982-1996 transfer reforms (RMI, APE), EITC-style natural experiment
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « the data used do not enable us to show any significant effect of financial incentives to work on men's transition from non-employment to employment »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
Pauline Givord and Claire Marbot (2015). Does the cost of child care affect female labor market participation? An evaluation of a French reform of childcare subsidies. Labour Economics, vol. 36, pp. 99-111.
- Design, as recorded: DiD exploiting PAJE 2004 discontinuity in childcare subsidies by child's year of birth
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: effect « the new policy results in a significant increase in the use of paid childcare services »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
Olivier Joseph et al. (2013). The economic impact of taking short parental leave: Evaluation of a French reform. Labour Economics.
- Design, as recorded: DiD and propensity score matching around 2004 PAJE reform (CLCA rank 1)
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « full-time short paid parental leave had almost no effect on labour market participation and wages of first mothers at the global level »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: lasts « The wages remain lower two years after child birth »
Zsuzsanna Makay (2023). Paid Parental Leave Reforms and Mothers' Employment in Austria, France and Hungary. Comparative Population Studies, vol. 48.
- Design, as recorded: Event-history analysis of mothers' labour market entry after birth, comparing periods defined by successive leave reforms
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « We found however, no significant effect of the 1986 reform for third children and the 2004 reform »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
Helene Perivier and Gregory Verdugo (2023). Where Are the Fathers? Effects of Earmarking Parental Leave for Fathers in France. ILR Review.
- Design, as recorded: Before/after comparison of parents of children born before vs after the 2015 PreParE reform (birth-date cohort comparison)
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « The reform increased mothers' labor earnings, but it had no significant impact on fathers' earnings. »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- a study of a cut
Mathilde Guergoat-Lariviere and Mathieu Narcy (2024). La reforme du conge parental de 2015 : un impact heterogene sur les meres et les peres selon les groupes sociaux et le contexte local. Revue d'economie politique, 134(2).
- Design, as recorded: RDD on child's birth date around January 2015
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: mixed « cette réforme n'a pas réellement encouragé les pères à prolonger le congé parental de leur conjointe à temps plein, certains l'ont fait à temps partiel »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- another outcome, not counted
- a study of a cut
Mathilde Guergoat-Lariviere et al. (2023). L'impact de la PreParE sur l'activite, les revenus et les modes de garde. Research report (HAL).
- Design, as recorded: RDD on child's birth date: births January 2015 vs December 2014
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: effect « la réduction d'un an de la durée d'indemnisation du congé parental a augmenté la probabilité des mères d'être en emploi »
- Leakage: leakage found « a contribué à augmenter le taux de recours à certains modes de garde formels »
- Permanence: mixed « mais également sur les trois années suivantes (+3,4 pp.) »
- a study of a cut
Mathieu Narcy and Florent Sari (2021). Quel est l'effet d'une reduction de la duree d'indemnisation du conge parental sur l'activite des meres ? Une evaluation de la reforme de 2015. Revue economique.
- Design, as recorded: RDD on child's birth date combined with DiD around January 2015 PreParE reform
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: effect « Cette réforme a eu pour conséquence de réduire la probabilité de recourir au congé parental à temps plein d'environ 10 points de pourcentage »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- another outcome, not counted
- a study of a cut
Helene Perivier and Gregory Verdugo (2021). Cinq ans apres la reforme du conge parental (PreParE), les objectifs sont-ils atteints ?. OFCE Policy Brief.
- Design, as recorded: Comparison of parents of children born before vs after the 2015 PreParE reform (method detailed in companion working paper)
- Goal measured: Reconcile family and working life (formal childcare coverage and cost, parents' employment, women-men pay gap; services to families)
- Impact: mixed « la réforme n'a pas eu d'effet sur la probabilité pour le couple d'avoir un autre enfant ou de se séparer »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- a study of a cut
Luc Behaghel and Maria Florencia Pinto (2024). Extended maternity leave and children's long-term development. Scandinavian Journal of Economics.
- Design, as recorded: Reform-based evaluation of the French three-year paid leave (design detail not stated in retrieved abstract)
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: no significant effect « a three‐year paid leave in France had zero average effects on children's long‐term schooling achievement »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: not informed
- another outcome, not counted
Clément de Chaisemartin et al. (2021). Lutter contre les inégalités dès la petite enfance : évaluation à grande échelle du programme Parler Bambin. Note IPP n° 72.
- Design, as recorded: randomised evaluation across 94 crèches: the year each crèche receives the training is drawn by lot
- Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
- Impact: mixed « Parler Bambin ne semble pas avoir d’effet sur le développement langagier des enfants mais produit un léger impact positif à court terme sur leur développement socio-affectif »
- Leakage: not informed
- Permanence: fades « Cet effet ne se maintient pas à long terme. »
- another outcome, not counted
Each study is coded by this site from the phrase quoted beside each verdict: impact on the goal it measures, leakage to people the law does not target, and permanence where the aim is a lasting change. The rows are in criteria.csv and studies.csv.
Searches
When the literature was searched
- 2026-10-04: every line, for causal evaluations of its measures and rules. Searched: the HAL, Crossref, OpenAlex, PubMed and IDEAS/RePEc catalogues of research and publishers' pages, line by line, and a general web search engine until its allowance ran out; some research departments' sites refused automated access, so a study they publish may have been missed (data/literature/gaps). Found: literature/studies.csv.
- 2026-10-18: causal evaluations of family benefits, parental leave, childcare and child protection since the search of 4 October 2026, and the institutes' reports on them. Searched: HAL API and OpenAlex, 14 queries in French and English on publications from 2025, and 4 on child protection with no date limit; the IPP site's search; the Drees publication page; ccomptes.fr search returned no results for a query (scripted page). Found: Parler Bambin, Note IPP n° 72 (2021), coded as study 368; the Cnaf-Drees note on the 2022 ASF increase (2025), a microsimulation, which corrects evaluations.csv row 30; no causal study of child protection; nothing new on parental leave or childcare subsidies.