Theme

Register of 2024 public money · GF0602

Community development

In short. Studies find urban renewal cut the poorest households' share only where demolition was heaviest and drew better-off buyers; the 2014 priority label drove families from local collèges.

2024

€27.2bn, of public money, line 20 of 155

Strength of evidence

Limited level 2 of 4, on 1 of its 6 goals: Social mix of deprived neighbourhoods (law) · on rules or parts of the line, which have no separate cost

Studies

6 causal studies tied; 2 findings on its goals

Summary

Version 1 · written 19 October 2026 · history

What it is and who gets it

Urban development by all public bodies, almost all of it by local authorities, and the State's policy for deprived neighbourhoods (politique de la ville), with its urban renewal programmes.

Goals and the evidence on each

  • Strengthen economic activity and functional mix in priority urban areas (density of establishments) (P147-1): no causal study found
  • Improve housing quality in urban-renewal neighbourhoods (NPNRU social housing rebuilt and upgraded) (P147-2): no causal study found
  • Real equal access to education, rights and public services for residents of deprived neighbourhoods (law): touched only, 1 study measures something it depends on
  • Social mix of deprived neighbourhoods (law): Limited, 2 findings
  • Fight discrimination against residents of deprived neighbourhoods, including by place of residence (law): no causal study found
  • Revitalise town centres: modernise housing and shop premises, fight vacancy (ORT): touched only, 1 study measures something it depends on

What the studies find

Of the 2 findings on its goals: 1 in the goal's direction, 1 mixed, 0 with no significant effect, 0 against it.

  • Where demolition was heaviest, a quarter of neighbourhoods, the 2003-2021 urban renewal programme (PNRU) cut the share of the poorest households by 5 points, with almost no average effect elsewhere (Pierre-Yves Cusset et al., 2024); it also raised home buyers' status relative to sellers (Lucie Letrouit, 2020).
  • After the 2014 redrawing of priority neighbourhoods, public collèges of newly labelled ones enrolled 3.5 points fewer of their catchment's sixth-graders, the better-off going private (Manon Garrouste and Miren Lafourcade, 2024); children given individual support (réussite éducative) progressed no more than matched children (Pascal Bressoux et al., 2016).
  • In declining small and mid-sized towns, the Action cœur de ville programme, with its Denormandie tax incentive, raised authorised housing by about 45%, mostly studios and small flats, with little effect on prices (Marie-Noëlle Lefebvre and Imen Daly, 2026).

What is missing

  • Local authorities spend almost all of this line; their own goals are not coded, and no causal study of their urban development spending was found (search of 19 October 2026).
  • No causal study of the new urban renewal programme (NPNRU) was found, and none measures the State's indicators, firms in priority areas and housing quality (the goals) (search notes).

This site's own evaluation (not counted): Petites villes de demain and Territoires d'industrie.

How this summary was made

Literature searched on 19 October 2026: causal evaluations of urban policy (priority neighbourhoods and their 2014 redrawing, urban renewal PNRU and NPNRU, emplois francs, educational success programmes, cités éducatives) and of town-centre programmes (Action cœur de ville, Petites villes de demain) since 2024, and the IPP's and France Stratégie's reports. Searched: the HAL API (9 queries in French and English, 2024-2026), the IPP site's search (2 queries) and the references of the notes found; the OpenAlex API answered with HTTP 429 (rate limit); Légifrance refused the shell (403), so the 2014 law was read through a fetch tool. Strength of evidence rated by the rule on the Method page.

  • Version 1, 19 October 2026, written · by writer: First version. Latest updates

Under the register's two definitions

Broad definition: a causal study in the line

evaluated

At least one causal study is tied to this line, on all of it or on one of its rules; the line then counts in full, so this is an upper bound.

Strict definition: a single measure with its own cost and study

not yet evaluated

A spending category: the register holds no separate cost for the measures inside it, so none of its money counts under this definition.

6 causal studies are tied to this line, the latest from 2026. The share of public money under each definition is on the evaluations page.

Against the Haut-commissariat's perimeters of aid to companies:

  • not placed: the report lists no measure of this line

The perimeters, and the share of each with a causal study

The literature

The studies that touch this line

  • Marie-Noëlle Lefebvre and Imen Daly (2026). Who Builds What When Subsidies Flow? Evidence from Place-Based Housing Policies in Small and Mid-Sized French Cities. Working paper (HAL).

    • Design, as recorded: difference-in-differences and event-study
    • Goal measured: Revitalise town centres: modernise housing and shop premises, fight vacancy (ORT)
    • Impact: touched « Policy exposure increases authorized housing supply by about 45% »
    • Leakage: no leakage found « we find little evidence of average price capitalization »
    • Permanence: not informed
    • a goal only touched, not counted
  • Lucie Letrouit (2020). Three essays on the economics of social integration in an urban context (PhD thesis, essay 3). PhD thesis (HAL theses).

    • Design, as recorded: DID_M estimator (de Chaisemartin and D'Haultfoeuille) plus traditional difference-in-differences
    • Goal measured: Social mix of deprived neighbourhoods (law)
    • Impact: effect « the program led to a sizable upward evolution in the socio-professional status of housing buyers as compared to sellers »
    • Leakage: not informed
    • Permanence: not informed
  • Sylvain Chareyron et al. (2022). Externalities from urban renewal: evidence from a French program. Regional Science and Urban Economics.

    • Design, as recorded: heterogeneity-robust difference-in-differences estimator, complemented by two-way fixed-effects DiD
    • Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
    • Impact: no significant effect « we find no significant aggregate impact of the program on housing prices »
    • Leakage: not informed
    • Permanence: not informed
    • another outcome, not counted
  • Manon Garrouste and Miren Lafourcade (2024). L’évitement scolaire : un effet « boomerang » de la labélisation en politique de la ville ?. Note IPP n° 110 (October 2024); working paper "Place-Based Policies: Opportunity for Deprived Schools or Zone-and-Shame Effect?" (HAL halshs-03899920).

    • Design, as recorded: collèges of neighbourhoods just below and just above the 2014 eligibility threshold of median income, compared before and after the reform (a difference in discontinuities); the school map was unchanged
    • Goal measured: an outcome that is not one of the line's goals; its reading has no colour and is not counted
    • Impact: adverse « les catégories plus favorisées davantage vers les collèges privés »
    • Leakage: not informed
    • Permanence: not informed
    • another outcome, not counted
  • Pierre-Yves Cusset et al. (2024). Quinze ans de PNRU : quels effets sur l’habitat et le peuplement ?. La Note d’analyse n° 133, France Stratégie (February 2024).

    • Design, as recorded: difference in differences: 497 neighbourhoods targeted by the PNRU against 240 similar zones urbaines sensibles not renovated, 1999-2019, with parallel trends checked before 2003
    • Goal measured: Social mix of deprived neighbourhoods (law)
    • Impact: mixed « une réduction de 5 points de la part des ménages les plus pauvres »
    • Leakage: not informed
    • Permanence: not informed
  • Pascal Bressoux et al. (2016). Évaluation des programmes de réussite éducative. Rapport IPP n° 13 (March 2016).

    • Design, as recorded: children in a programme compared, after 20 months, with children of similar baseline characteristics from schools outside the programmes' areas, matched on a survey of 2012
    • Goal measured: Real equal access to education, rights and public services for residents of deprived neighbourhoods (law)
    • Impact: touched « leurs compétences en mathématiques et français évoluent de manière similaire au groupe témoin »
    • Leakage: not informed
    • Permanence: not informed
    • a goal only touched, not counted

Each study is coded by this site from the phrase quoted beside each verdict: impact on the goal it measures, leakage to people the law does not target, and permanence where the aim is a lasting change. The rows are in criteria.csv and studies.csv.

This site

This site's own evaluation

  • Petites villes de demain and Territoires d'industrie · This site's evaluation

    • Impact: mixed « Private jobs moved by -0.3% (Petites villes de demain, 95% confidence interval -2.1% to +1.5%) and +0.0% (Territoires d'industrie, -2.4% to +2.5%) against matched communes by 2025; placebos pass. Industrial jobs in the communes of Territoires d'industrie moved by -6.5% between the 2015 and 2021 censuses (95% interval -11.4% to -1.5%). »
    • Leakage: not informed
    • Permanence: not informed

Searches

When the literature was searched

  • 2026-10-04: every line, for causal evaluations of its measures and rules. Searched: the HAL, Crossref, OpenAlex, PubMed and IDEAS/RePEc catalogues of research and publishers' pages, line by line, and a general web search engine until its allowance ran out; some research departments' sites refused automated access, so a study they publish may have been missed (data/literature/gaps). Found: literature/studies.csv.
  • 2026-10-19: causal evaluations of urban policy (priority neighbourhoods and their 2014 redrawing, urban renewal PNRU and NPNRU, emplois francs, educational success programmes, cités éducatives) and of town-centre programmes (Action cœur de ville, Petites villes de demain) since 2024, and the IPP's and France Stratégie's reports. Searched: the HAL API (9 queries in French and English, 2024-2026), the IPP site's search (2 queries) and the references of the notes found; the OpenAlex API answered with HTTP 429 (rate limit); Légifrance refused the shell (403), so the 2014 law was read through a fetch tool. Found: Garrouste and Lafourcade (Note IPP n° 110, 2024) on the 2014 priority label and school avoidance, coded as study 385; Cusset et al. (France Stratégie, Note d'analyse n° 133, 2024) on fifteen years of the PNRU, coded as study 386; Bressoux et al. (Rapport IPP n° 13, 2016) on the programmes de réussite éducative, coded as study 387; not coded: qualitative studies of cités éducatives and urban renewal, a chapter on Action cœur de ville in the Grand Est (no abstract), a study of mountain farm subsidies (another line).

Back to every line of the register

Sources: Eurostat, Ministère de l'Économie et des Finances, Direction de la Sécurité sociale, and the publishers of the studies, each named in its panel.

The page is static HTML and reads in full without JavaScript. The script adds the tooltips, traces a flow through a diagram, opens in place the evidence kept on separate pages, shows and hides the diagrams on a phone, recomputes the wealth calculator, places you on the page that asks where you stand, and keeps the theme you pick: light, dark or high contrast.

Questions, ideas or corrections: open an issue at github.com/samoht/budget/issues. Who makes this site, and the corrections made to it, are on the Method page.

Every data file, with its columns, licence and checksum: the Data page. Every chart, by question: the index of the charts. Every line of the register: the register's index.

The evidence summaries of the register as they are written: Latest updates (Atom feed).

Text and data: Licence Ouverte / Open Licence 2.0, except third-party data, which keep their publishers' terms. Code: ISC. See LICENSE.md.

Version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, built on 2026-11-12 from ef7a7ba2.