Theme

Official figures and this site's calculations

Why believe this?

Figures of one view and year of the diagram, with their sources and how they were computed, each under its own anchor. Back to Who pays and who receives, by group of people, 2023 and 2024.

7 parts: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Why believe this?

Net lending

€−151.9bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
Revenue minus expenditure of general government.

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset gov_10a_main (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=MIO_EUR sector=S13 na_item=B9 time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€−151,920.3 million
Dataset version
updated 2026-07-21, read 2026-10-14

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-b9: Net lending, €−151.9bn (2023), from Eurostat gov_10a_main (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-b9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Benefits from other schemes

€127.4bnObservedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Cash benefits households receive from employers', insurers' and foreign schemes, D62 received by households less D62 paid by general government, and the services of non-profit institutions, their individual consumption (P31 of S15): Insee counts both, general government pays neither.

Calculation

Computed as
D62, Households received, 2023 − D62, General government paid, 2023 + P31, Non-profit institutions serving households paid, 2023
From
  • D62, Households received, 2023 €591.8bn
  • D62, General government paid, 2023 €529.7bn
  • P31, Non-profit institutions serving households paid, 2023 €65.3bn
Result
€127,415.0 million

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-schemes-benefits: Benefits from other schemes, €127.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-schemes-benefits.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

D5, Households paid, 2023

€273.3bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
A transaction of the sector accounts (ESA 2010), at current prices (Eurostat nasa_10_nf_tr).

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset nasa_10_nf_tr (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=CP_MEUR direct=PAID sector=S14 na_item=D5 time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€273,270.0 million · flagged provisional by Eurostat
Dataset version
updated 2026-10-14, read 2026-10-18

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-nasa-s14-paid-d5: D5, Households paid, 2023, €273.3bn (2023), from Eurostat nasa_10_nf_tr (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-nasa-s14-paid-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

D63, Households received, 2023

€505.9bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
A transaction of the sector accounts (ESA 2010), at current prices (Eurostat nasa_10_nf_tr).

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset nasa_10_nf_tr (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=CP_MEUR direct=RECV sector=S14 na_item=D63 time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€505,920.0 million · flagged provisional by Eurostat
Dataset version
updated 2026-10-14, read 2026-10-18

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-nasa-s14-recv-d63: D63, Households received, 2023, €505.9bn (2023), from Eurostat nasa_10_nf_tr (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-nasa-s14-recv-d63.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

P32, General government paid, 2023

€241.5bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
A transaction of the sector accounts (ESA 2010), at current prices (Eurostat nasa_10_nf_tr).

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset nasa_10_nf_tr (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=CP_MEUR direct=PAID sector=S13 na_item=P32 time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€241,543.0 million · flagged provisional by Eurostat
Dataset version
updated 2026-10-14, read 2026-10-18

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-nasa-s13-paid-p32: P32, General government paid, 2023, €241.5bn (2023), from Eurostat nasa_10_nf_tr (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-nasa-s13-paid-p32.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Dividends paid by the Banque de France, 2015 to 2022

€15.5bnObserved2022

Definition

What it counts
Dividends the Banque de France paid the State over 2015 to 2022.

Where it comes from

Source
Banque de France, Banque de France
Where
Billet de blog d'Agnès Bénassy-Quéré, March 2025, citing the Rapport annuel 2024, p. 117; raw/bdf_blog_abq_pertes_2025.pdf
Published
March 2025
It says
From 2015 to 2022 the Bank paid the State €16.3bn of corporate tax and €15.5bn of dividends.
As published
€15.5 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-bdf-dividend-2015-2022: Dividends paid by the Banque de France, 2015 to 2022, €15.5bn (2022), from Banque de France (2025), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-bdf-dividend-2015-2022.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Share of public debt held by the Banque de France

21.9%EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
A holder's average holdings of public debt over the year, as a share of all holders'.
Caveat
Interest split by the average of the holdings at the start and end of the year: Eurostat does not publish interest paid by government by holder. Holders of older, low-coupon bonds receive less than their share of the stock. The Banque de France bought most of its holdings in 2015 to 2022 at low coupons; the Eurosystem stopped reinvesting maturing bonds of its asset purchase programme (APP) in July 2023 and of its pandemic programme (PEPP) at the end of 2024 (ECB), so its share of the stock falls.

Calculation

Computed as
(Public debt held by the central bank, end 2022 + Public debt held by the central bank, end 2023) ÷ (Public debt, all holders, end 2022 + Public debt, all holders, end 2023) × 100
From
  • Public debt held by the central bank, end 2022 €667.7bn
  • Public debt held by the central bank, end 2023 €660.9bn
  • Public debt, all holders, end 2022 €2,956bn
  • Public debt, all holders, end 2023 €3,103bn
Result
21.9%

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-held-bdf: Share of public debt held by the Banque de France, 21.9% (2023), calculated by this site from Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-held-bdf.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Share of net borrowing from the Banque de France

−4.6%EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
A holder's net take-up of public debt over the year, as a share of all holders': the change in its holdings at face value.
Caveat
Net take-up at face value: the change in what each sector holds over the year, which also moves when bonds change hands between sectors. Eurostat does not publish government debt transactions by holder; changes at face value carry no market revaluation, so they are the closest published measure. The total change in debt differs from the deficit by the stock-flow adjustment (cash buffers, premiums and discounts at issue), so the shares, not the amounts, are applied to the deficit.

Calculation

Computed as
(Public debt held by the central bank, end 2023 − Public debt held by the central bank, end 2022) ÷ (Public debt, all holders, end 2023 − Public debt, all holders, end 2022) × 100
From
  • Public debt held by the central bank, end 2022 €667.7bn
  • Public debt held by the central bank, end 2023 €660.9bn
  • Public debt, all holders, end 2022 €2,956bn
  • Public debt, all holders, end 2023 €3,103bn
Result
−4.6%

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-takeup-bdf: Share of net borrowing from the Banque de France, −4.6% (2023), calculated by this site from Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-takeup-bdf.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Capital transfers to the rest of the world

€373mObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
A transfer between French general government and the rest of the world, as Eurostat records it in the government accounts.

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset gov_10a_main (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=MIO_EUR sector=S13 na_item=D9PAY_S2 time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€373.0 million
Dataset version
updated 2026-07-21, read 2026-10-14

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-row-d9pay_s2: Capital transfers to the rest of the world, €373m (2023), from Eurostat gov_10a_main (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-row-d9pay_s2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Capital income's share of the CSG, 2023

11.3%EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The CSG's yield on capital income over its yield on earnings, replacement income and capital income (CCSS); the CSG on gaming is left out.

Calculation

Computed as
CSG on capital income, 2023 ÷ (CSG on earnings, 2023 + CSG on replacement income, 2023 + CSG on capital income, 2023) × 100
From
Result
11.3%

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-csg-capital-ratio: Capital income's share of the CSG, 2023, 11.3% (2023), calculated by this site from Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-csg-capital-ratio.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

All groups, Subsidies on products

€32bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the groups' amounts, as Insee rounds them.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 10–20%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 20–30%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 30–40%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 40–50%, Subsidies on products + Top 40–50%, Subsidies on products + Top 30–40%, Subsidies on products + Top 20–30%, Subsidies on products + Top 10–20%, Subsidies on products + Top 10%, Subsidies on products
From
Result
€32.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-subsidies_products-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10: All groups, Subsidies on products, €32bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-subsidies_products-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Subsidies on products

€2.8bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Subsidies paid per unit sold, public transport above all, attributed to the households who consume.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 19 “Subventions sur les produits (transports, etc.)”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 19, V3: 1.4; row 19, V4: 1.4
As published
€2.8 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-subsidies_products-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Subsidies on products, €2.8bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-subsidies_products-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Subsidies on production

€1.1bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Apprenticeship hiring aid, sector aid and other subsidies to producers, attributed to households.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 21 “Subventions sur la production (aides à l'apprentissage, aides sectorielles, etc.)”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 21, V3: 0.5; row 21, V4: 0.6
As published
€1.1 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-subsidies_production-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Subsidies on production, €1.1bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-subsidies_production-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

All twentieths, Pensions

€397.8bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Insee's 2023 rows summed over its twenty twentieths.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 31 “Pensions de retraite”, columns C and D and E and F and G and H and I and J and K and L and M and N and O and P and Q and R and S and T and U and V (V1 + V2 + V3 + V4 + V5 + V6 + V7 + V8 + V9 + V10 + V11 + V12 + V13 + V14 + V15 + V16 + V17 + V18 + V19 + V20), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 31, V1: 2.4; row 31, V2: 8.2; row 31, V3: 10.5; row 31, V4: 12.2; row 31, V5: 15.3; row 31, V6: 18.9; row 31, V7: 18.6; row 31, V8: 17.7; row 31, V9: 18.9; row 31, V10: 20.1; row 31, V11: 20.2; row 31, V12: 23.4; row 31, V13: 20.9; row 31, V14: 23.8; row 31, V15: 23.1; row 31, V16: 24.7; row 31, V17: 24.4; row 31, V18: 27.9; row 31, V19: 30.2; row 31, V20: 36.4
As published
€397.8 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-pensions-twentieths: All twentieths, Pensions, €397.8bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-pensions-twentieths.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, Pensions

€34.2bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Retirement pensions, survivors' pensions included.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 31 “Pensions de retraite”, columns G and H (V5 + V6), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 31, V5: 15.3; row 31, V6: 18.9
As published
€34.2 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-pensions-d3: Bottom 20–30%, Pensions, €34.2bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-pensions-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Pensions

€47.8bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Retirement pensions, survivors' pensions included.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 31 “Pensions de retraite”, columns Q and R (V15 + V16), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 31, V15: 23.1; row 31, V16: 24.7
As published
€47.8 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-pensions-d8: Top 20–30%, Pensions, €47.8bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-pensions-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Unemployment benefits

€5.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Unemployment insurance and solidarity benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
Unemployment benefits × Top 10%, Unemployment benefits ÷ All groups, Unemployment benefits
From
Result
€5.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-unemployment_benefits-d10: Top 10%, Unemployment benefits, €5.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-unemployment_benefits-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Unemployment benefits

€45.8bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Unemployment insurance and solidarity benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
All twentieths, Unemployment benefits
From
Result
€45.8 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-unemployment_benefits: Unemployment benefits, €45.8bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-unemployment_benefits.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, Unemployment benefits

€5.8bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Unemployment insurance and solidarity benefits.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 32 “Allocations chômage”, columns C and D (V1 + V2), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 32, V1: 2.5; row 32, V2: 3.3
As published
€5.8 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-unemployment_benefits-d1: Bottom 10%, Unemployment benefits, €5.8bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-unemployment_benefits-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Unemployment benefits

€3.4bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Unemployment insurance and solidarity benefits.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 32 “Allocations chômage”, columns Q and R (V15 + V16), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 32, V15: 1.8; row 32, V16: 1.6
As published
€3.4 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-unemployment_benefits-d8: Top 20–30%, Unemployment benefits, €3.4bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-unemployment_benefits-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

All groups, Other cash benefits

€147.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the groups' amounts, as Insee rounds them.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Other cash benefits + Bottom 10–20%, Other cash benefits + Bottom 20–30%, Other cash benefits + Bottom 30–40%, Other cash benefits + Bottom 40–50%, Other cash benefits + Top 40–50%, Other cash benefits + Top 30–40%, Other cash benefits + Top 20–30%, Other cash benefits + Top 10–20%, Other cash benefits + Top 10%, Other cash benefits
From
Result
€147.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-other_cash-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10: All groups, Other cash benefits, €147.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-other_cash-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Other cash benefits

€21.1bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Sick pay and work-injury benefits, family benefits, minimum incomes, disability benefits, and the reimbursements of firms' group health insurance, which Insee counts among cash benefits.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, rows 33 “Autres revenus de remplacement (IJ, ATMP)”; 34 “Famille”; 35 “Exclusion sociale”; 36 “Invalidité”; 37 “Remboursements des contrats collectifs de complémentaires santé”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 33, V3: 0.6; row 33, V4: 0.7; row 34, V3: 3.2; row 34, V4: 3; row 35, V3: 4.1; row 35, V4: 4.3; row 36, V3: 2.1; row 36, V4: 1.5; row 37, V3: 0.8; row 37, V4: 0.8
As published
€21.1 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-other_cash-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Other cash benefits, €21.1bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-other_cash-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, Other cash benefits

€13bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Sick pay and work-injury benefits, family benefits, minimum incomes, disability benefits, and the reimbursements of firms' group health insurance, which Insee counts among cash benefits.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, rows 33 “Autres revenus de remplacement (IJ, ATMP)”; 34 “Famille”; 35 “Exclusion sociale”; 36 “Invalidité”; 37 “Remboursements des contrats collectifs de complémentaires santé”, columns K and L (V9 + V10), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 33, V9: 1.5; row 33, V10: 1.6; row 34, V9: 1.7; row 34, V10: 1.7; row 35, V9: 1.4; row 35, V10: 0.9; row 36, V9: 1.1; row 36, V10: 1.1; row 37, V9: 1; row 37, V10: 1
As published
€13.0 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-other_cash-d5: Bottom 40–50%, Other cash benefits, €13bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-other_cash-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, Health care

€24bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Care paid for by public health insurance and hospitals, received in kind.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 40 “Santé”, columns G and H (V5 + V6), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 40, V5: 11.8; row 40, V6: 12.2
As published
€24.0 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-health-d3: Bottom 20–30%, Health care, €24bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-health-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Education

€10.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Schooling from nursery to university, school transport included, received in kind.

Calculation

Computed as
Education × Top 10%, Education ÷ All groups, Education
From
Result
€10.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-education-d10: Top 10%, Education, €10.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-education-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Education

€10.4bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Schooling from nursery to university, school transport included, received in kind.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 41 “Enseignement2”, columns U and V (V19 + V20), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 41, V19: 5.1; row 41, V20: 5.3
As published
€10.4 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-education-d10: Top 10%, Education, €10.4bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-education-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, Education

€18.7bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Schooling from nursery to university, school transport included, received in kind.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 41 “Enseignement2”, columns C and D (V1 + V2), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 41, V1: 9.8; row 41, V2: 8.9
As published
€18.7 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-education-d1: Bottom 10%, Education, €18.7bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-education-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Social care and housing aid

€22.4bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Care for dependent elderly and disabled people, childcare and other social action, housing benefits and the energy cheque, and the running costs of social security, received in kind.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, rows 42 “Action sociale (dépendance, handicap, petite enfance, etc.)”; 44 “Aides au logement et chèque énergie”; 45 “Frais de fonctionnement de la Sécurité sociale”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 42, V3: 7; row 42, V4: 8.8; row 44, V3: 2.6; row 44, V4: 1.9; row 45, V3: 1; row 45, V4: 1.1
As published
€22.4 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-other_in_kind-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Social care and housing aid, €22.4bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-other_in_kind-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Culture and leisure

€52bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Public culture, sport and leisure services, spread equally per person.

Calculation

Computed as
All twentieths, Culture and leisure
From
Result
€52.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-culture: Culture and leisure, €52bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-culture.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Culture and leisure

€5.2bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Public culture, sport and leisure services, spread equally per person.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 43 “Culture et loisirs”, columns M and N (V11 + V12), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 43, V11: 2.6; row 43, V12: 2.6
As published
€5.2 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-culture-d6: Top 40–50%, Culture and leisure, €5.2bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-culture-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, Collective services

€23.4bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Defence, police, justice, general administration and other collective spending, Insee's row 47, which Insee spreads over people though not equally, its cells giving more per person in the first and last twentieths; net of other transfers and balances with the rest of the world, row 48, small overall, positive at the bottom and negative at the top.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 46 “Autres transferts non monétaires”, columns K and L (V9 + V10), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 46, V9: 11.8; row 46, V10: 11.6
As published
€23.4 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-collective_and_other-d5: Bottom 40–50%, Collective services, €23.4bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-collective_and_other-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, Taxes on products

€27bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
VAT, energy and other excise duties and property transfer duties, collected by firms on what they sell; Insee attributes them to the households who consume.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 18 “Taxes sur les produits (TVA, TICPE, accises, DMTO, etc.)”, columns I and J (V7 + V8), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 18, V7: -13.2; row 18, V8: -13.8
As published
€27.0 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-taxes_products-d4: Bottom 30–40%, Taxes on products, €27bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-taxes_products-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

All groups, Taxes on production

€127.9bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the groups' amounts, as Insee rounds them.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Taxes on production + Bottom 10–20%, Taxes on production + Bottom 20–30%, Taxes on production + Bottom 30–40%, Taxes on production + Bottom 40–50%, Taxes on production + Top 40–50%, Taxes on production + Top 30–40%, Taxes on production + Top 20–30%, Taxes on production + Top 10–20%, Taxes on production + Top 10%, Taxes on production
From
Result
€127.9 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-taxes_production-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10: All groups, Taxes on production, €127.9bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-taxes_production-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, Taxes on production

€2.2bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Payroll taxes, business property tax and other taxes firms pay for producing, attributed to households.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 20 “Taxes sur la production (taxes patronales, TF, etc.)”, columns C and D (V1 + V2), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 20, V1: -0.9; row 20, V2: -1.3
As published
€2.2 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-taxes_production-d1: Bottom 10%, Taxes on production, €2.2bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-taxes_production-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Taxes on production

€16.5bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Payroll taxes, business property tax and other taxes firms pay for producing, attributed to households.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 20 “Taxes sur la production (taxes patronales, TF, etc.)”, columns Q and R (V15 + V16), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 20, V15: -7.9; row 20, V16: -8.6
As published
€16.5 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-taxes_production-d8: Top 20–30%, Taxes on production, €16.5bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-taxes_production-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Corporate tax

€64.1bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Corporate income tax, attributed to the households who own the companies.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 22 “Impôt sur les sociétés”, columns U and V (V19 + V20), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 22, V19: -6.7; row 22, V20: -57.4
As published
€64.1 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-corporate_tax-d10: Top 10%, Corporate tax, €64.1bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-corporate_tax-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Corporate tax

€600mEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Corporate income tax, attributed to the households who own the companies.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 22 “Impôt sur les sociétés”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 22, V3: -0.3; row 22, V4: -0.3
As published
€0.6 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-corporate_tax-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Corporate tax, €600m (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-corporate_tax-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, Corporate tax

€4.6bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Corporate income tax, attributed to the households who own the companies.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 22 “Impôt sur les sociétés”, columns S and T (V17 + V18), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 22, V17: -2; row 22, V18: -2.6
As published
€4.6 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-corporate_tax-d9: Top 10–20%, Corporate tax, €4.6bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-corporate_tax-d9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, CSG

€15.7bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
The generalised social contribution, levied on earnings, benefits and capital income.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 23 “Contribution sociale généralisée (CSG)”, columns O and P (V13 + V14), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 23, V13: -7.6; row 23, V14: -8.1
As published
€15.7 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-csg-d7: Top 30–40%, CSG, €15.7bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-csg-d7.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Net financial income

€2.1bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Interest, dividends and other property income households receive, less the interest they pay.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 8 “Revenus financiers nets (intérêts, dividendes, etc.)”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 8, V3: 1; row 8, V4: 1.1
As published
€2.1 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-financial-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Net financial income, €2.1bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-financial-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Rents, actual and imputed

€36.3bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Rents landlords receive and the rent owner-occupiers are deemed to pay themselves, net of costs.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 9 “Loyers réels et imputés aux propriétaires”, columns U and V (V19 + V20), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 9, V19: 14.9; row 9, V20: 21.4
As published
€36.3 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-rents-d10: Top 10%, Rents, actual and imputed, €36.3bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-rents-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, Rents, actual and imputed

€13.9bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Rents landlords receive and the rent owner-occupiers are deemed to pay themselves, net of costs.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 9 “Loyers réels et imputés aux propriétaires”, columns K and L (V9 + V10), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 9, V9: 6.8; row 9, V10: 7.1
As published
€13.9 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-rents-d5: Bottom 40–50%, Rents, actual and imputed, €13.9bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-rents-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

All groups, Income tax

€101.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the groups' amounts, as Insee rounds them.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Income tax + Bottom 10–20%, Income tax + Bottom 20–30%, Income tax + Bottom 30–40%, Income tax + Bottom 40–50%, Income tax + Top 40–50%, Income tax + Top 30–40%, Income tax + Top 20–30%, Income tax + Top 10–20%, Income tax + Top 10%, Income tax
From
Result
€101.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-income_tax-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10: All groups, Income tax, €101.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-income_tax-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Income tax

€100mEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Personal income tax, net of refundable credits.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 24 “Impôt sur le revenu (IR)”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 24, V3: 0; row 24, V4: -0.1
As published
€0.1 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-income_tax-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Income tax, €100m (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-income_tax-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, Other taxes on income and wealth

€400mEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Residence tax, the wealth tax on property (IFI), CRDS and other taxes on income and wealth.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 25 “Autres impôts sur les revenus et le patrimoine (TH, ISF/IFI, CRDS, etc.)”, columns C and D (V1 + V2), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 25, V1: -0.2; row 25, V2: -0.2
As published
€0.4 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-other_income_taxes-d1: Bottom 10%, Other taxes on income and wealth, €400m (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-other_income_taxes-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Other taxes on income and wealth

€1.5bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Residence tax, the wealth tax on property (IFI), CRDS and other taxes on income and wealth.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 25 “Autres impôts sur les revenus et le patrimoine (TH, ISF/IFI, CRDS, etc.)”, columns M and N (V11 + V12), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 25, V11: -0.7; row 25, V12: -0.8
As published
€1.5 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-other_income_taxes-d6: Top 40–50%, Other taxes on income and wealth, €1.5bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-other_income_taxes-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Pension contributions

€93bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Employer and employee contributions to pension schemes, imputed contributions and firms' collective schemes included.

Calculation

Computed as
Pension contributions × Top 10%, Pension contributions ÷ All groups, Pension contributions
From
Result
€93.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-contrib_pensions-d10: Top 10%, Pension contributions, €93bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-contrib_pensions-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, Pension contributions

€24.9bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Employer and employee contributions to pension schemes, imputed contributions and firms' collective schemes included.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 26 “Cotisations sociales retraite1”, columns K and L (V9 + V10), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 26, V9: -12; row 26, V10: -12.9
As published
€24.9 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-contrib_pensions-d5: Bottom 40–50%, Pension contributions, €24.9bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-contrib_pensions-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

All groups, Other contributions

€214bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the groups' amounts, as Insee rounds them.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Other contributions + Bottom 10–20%, Other contributions + Bottom 20–30%, Other contributions + Bottom 30–40%, Other contributions + Bottom 40–50%, Other contributions + Top 40–50%, Other contributions + Top 30–40%, Other contributions + Top 20–30%, Other contributions + Top 10–20%, Other contributions + Top 10%, Other contributions
From
Result
€214.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-contrib_others-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10: All groups, Other contributions, €214bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-contrib_others-groups-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, people

6.8 millionEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Individuals of all ages, as Insee counts them in its distributional accounts.

Calculation

Computed as
(Everyone, Individuals, millions, Insee × 0.1) × 1,000,000
From
Result
6,840,000

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-people-d1: Bottom 10%, people, 6.8 million (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-people-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, profits kept in companies, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data

€10EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Profits kept in companies × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 10%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€10

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-capital-retained-d1-pp: Bottom 10%, profits kept in companies, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data, €10 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-capital-retained-d1-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, received a month per person

€1,570EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, transfers received × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 10%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,570

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d1-pp: Bottom 10%, received a month per person, €1,570 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d1-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, Pensions

€10.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Retirement pensions, survivors' pensions included.

Calculation

Computed as
Pensions × Bottom 10%, Pensions ÷ All groups, Pensions
From
Result
€10.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-pensions-d1: Bottom 10%, Pensions, €10.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-pensions-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, Other cash benefits

€20.8bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Sick pay and work-injury benefits, family benefits, minimum incomes, disability benefits, and the reimbursements of firms' group health insurance, which Insee counts among cash benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
Other cash benefits × Bottom 10%, Other cash benefits ÷ All groups, Other cash benefits
From
Result
€20.8 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-other_cash-d1: Bottom 10%, Other cash benefits, €20.8bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-other_cash-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

General public services

€174.8bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
Executive and legislative bodies, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs and debt interest.

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset gov_10a_exp (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=MIO_EUR sector=S13 na_item=TE cofog99=GF01 time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€174,763.5 million · flagged provisional by Eurostat
Dataset version
updated 2026-09-16, read 2026-10-14

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-gf01: General public services, €174.8bn (2023), from Eurostat gov_10a_exp (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-gf01.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Insee's items in category gf07, all groups

€209.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of Insee's 2023 items of the category over the groups.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Health care + Bottom 10–20%, Health care + Bottom 20–30%, Health care + Bottom 30–40%, Health care + Bottom 40–50%, Health care + Top 40–50%, Health care + Top 30–40%, Health care + Top 20–30%, Health care + Top 10–20%, Health care + Top 10%, Health care
From
Result
€209.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-cat-gf07-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10: Insee's items in category gf07, all groups, €209.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-cat-gf07-d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, received a month per person, collective services by income

€1,320EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, transfers received, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 10%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,320

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d1-pp-by-income: Bottom 10%, received a month per person, collective services by income, €1,320 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d1-pp-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, Collective services

€24.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Defence, police, justice, general administration and other collective spending, Insee's row 47, which Insee spreads over people though not equally, its cells giving more per person in the first and last twentieths; net of other transfers and balances with the rest of the world, row 48, small overall, positive at the bottom and negative at the top.

Calculation

Computed as
Collective services × Bottom 20–30%, Collective services ÷ All groups, Collective services
From
Result
€24.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-collective_and_other-d3: Bottom 20–30%, Collective services, €24.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-collective_and_other-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Extended primary income

€57.7bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Income before any public transfer, Insee's row 14.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 14 “Revenu primaire élargi (D=A+B+C)”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 14, V3: 25.3; row 14, V4: 32.4
As published
€57.7 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-primary-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Extended primary income, €57.7bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-primary-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Levies, net of subsidies

€41bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, net of the subsidies on products and on production, Insee's row 17.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 17 “Prélèvements (I)”, columns E and F (V3 + V4), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 17, V3: -18.3; row 17, V4: -22.7
As published
€41.0 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-levies_total-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Levies, net of subsidies, €41bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-levies_total-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, income after levies and cash benefits

€112.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Insee's extended primary income less levies, net of subsidies, plus cash benefits: rows 14, 17 and 30 of its detailed table, 2023.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, Extended primary income − Bottom 40–50%, Levies, net of subsidies + Bottom 40–50%, Cash benefits
From
Result
€112.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-income-d5: Bottom 40–50%, income after levies and cash benefits, €112.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-income-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Cash benefits

€59bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Cash social benefits, pensions included, Insee's row 30.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 30 “Prestations sociales monétaires (ii)”, columns M and N (V11 + V12), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 30, V11: 28.1; row 30, V12: 30.9
As published
€59.0 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-cash_total-d6: Top 40–50%, Cash benefits, €59bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-cash_total-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, Extended primary income

€316.5bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Income before any public transfer, Insee's row 14.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 14 “Revenu primaire élargi (D=A+B+C)”, columns S and T (V17 + V18), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 14, V17: 146; row 14, V18: 170.5
As published
€316.5 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-primary-d9: Top 10–20%, Extended primary income, €316.5bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-primary-d9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, Levies, net of subsidies

€422.8bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, net of the subsidies on products and on production, Insee's row 17.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 17 “Prélèvements (I)”, columns U and V (V19 + V20), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 17, V19: -129.9; row 17, V20: -292.9
As published
€422.8 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-levies_total-d10: Top 10%, Levies, net of subsidies, €422.8bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-levies_total-d10.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay

€1,370EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 10%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,370

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d1-pp-deferred: Bottom 10%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, €1,370 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d1-pp-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out

€85.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Replacement income counts as deferred pay, as in Insee's box: pensions, unemployment benefits and the other replacement income (sick pay and work-injury annuities), Insee's rows 31 to 33, are left out. Collective services, Insee's row 46, go to no group and are left out.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, transfers received − Bottom 10%, Pensions − Bottom 10%, Unemployment benefits − Bottom 10%, other replacement income − Bottom 10%, Collective services
From
Result
€85.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d1-deferred-shared-out: Bottom 10%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out, €85.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d1-deferred-shared-out.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Taxes on production and imports

€446.9bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
VAT, excise duties on energy, tobacco and alcohol, and taxes on payroll and on business property, as received by general government.

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset gov_10a_main (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=MIO_EUR sector=S13 na_item=D2REC time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€446,907.0 million
Dataset version
updated 2026-07-21, read 2026-10-14

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-d2rec: Taxes on production and imports, €446.9bn (2023), from Eurostat gov_10a_main (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-d2rec.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Taxes on income and wealth

€357.2bnObserved2023

Definition

What it counts
Personal income tax, CSG and CRDS, corporate income tax, and the property wealth tax (IFI).

Where it comes from

Source
Eurostat, dataset gov_10a_main (browse the table)
Exact cell
geo=FR unit=MIO_EUR sector=S13 na_item=D5REC time=2023 · query this cell
As published
€357,244.0 million
Dataset version
updated 2026-07-21, read 2026-10-14

Calculation

Transformation
Divided by 1,000 to give billions, then rounded for display.

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-d5rec: Taxes on income and wealth, €357.2bn (2023), from Eurostat gov_10a_main (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-d5rec.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, paid a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay

€350EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, levies paid, replacement income as deferred pay × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 10%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€350

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d1-pp-deferred: Bottom 10%, paid a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, €350 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d1-pp-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, received a month per person

€1,820EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10–20%, transfers received × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 10–20%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,820

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d2-pp: Bottom 10–20%, received a month per person, €1,820 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d2-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Social care and housing aid

€22.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Care for dependent elderly and disabled people, childcare and other social action, housing benefits and the energy cheque, and the running costs of social security, received in kind.

Calculation

Computed as
Social care and housing aid × Bottom 10–20%, Social care and housing aid ÷ All groups, Social care and housing aid
From
Result
€22.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-other_in_kind-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Social care and housing aid, €22.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-other_in_kind-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, collective services by income

€11.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Collective services, Insee's row 46, of all groups in the year, shared in proportion to each group's income after levies and cash benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
All groups, collective services × Bottom 10–20%, income after levies and cash benefits ÷ All groups, income after levies and cash benefits
From
Result
€11.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-collective_and_other-d2-by-income: Bottom 10–20%, collective services by income, €11.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-collective_and_other-d2-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay

€119.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Replacement income counts as deferred pay, as in Insee's box: pensions, unemployment benefits and the other replacement income (sick pay and work-injury annuities), Insee's rows 31 to 33, are left out.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10–20%, transfers received − Bottom 10–20%, Pensions − Bottom 10–20%, Unemployment benefits − Bottom 10–20%, other replacement income
From
Result
€119.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d2-deferred: Bottom 10–20%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, €119.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d2-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, Corporate tax

€600mEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Corporate income tax, attributed to the households who own the companies.

Calculation

Computed as
Corporate tax × Bottom 10–20%, Corporate tax ÷ All groups, Corporate tax
From
Result
€0.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-corporate_tax-d2: Bottom 10–20%, Corporate tax, €600m (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-corporate_tax-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, CSG on earnings and benefits

€3.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The CSG on earnings, pensions and other replacement income, and on gaming: the CSG less its part on capital income.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10–20%, CSG − Bottom 10–20%, CSG on capital income
From
Result
€3.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-csg-rest-d2: Bottom 10–20%, CSG on earnings and benefits, €3.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-csg-rest-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, rents, actual and imputed, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data

€130EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 20–30%, Rents, actual and imputed × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€130

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-capital-rents-d3-pp: Bottom 20–30%, rents, actual and imputed, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data, €130 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-capital-rents-d3-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, received a month per person

€1,740EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 20–30%, transfers received × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,740

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d3-pp: Bottom 20–30%, received a month per person, €1,740 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d3-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€154bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Each of Insee's 2023 items of the group is scaled to Eurostat's total of its category for the year, S13 receipts for levies and COFOG total expenditure for spending, as this site computed every year before October 2026: total expenditure holds investment and capital transfers that no household receives in the year.

Calculation

Computed as
Σ over Insee's items of the group's 2023 amount × the category's Eurostat total for the year ÷ Insee's items of the category, all groups
From
Result
€154.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d3-cofog: Bottom 20–30%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €154bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d3-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, Other replacement income

€1.9bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Sick pay (indemnités journalières) and work-injury and occupational disease annuities, Insee's row 33.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 33 “Autres revenus de remplacement (IJ, ATMP)”, columns G and H (V5 + V6), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 33, V5: 0.9; row 33, V6: 1
As published
€1.9 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-replacement-d3: Bottom 20–30%, Other replacement income, €1.9bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-replacement-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out

€77.1bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Replacement income counts as deferred pay, as in Insee's box: pensions, unemployment benefits and the other replacement income (sick pay and work-injury annuities), Insee's rows 31 to 33, are left out. Collective services, Insee's row 46, go to no group and are left out.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 20–30%, transfers received − Bottom 20–30%, Pensions − Bottom 20–30%, Unemployment benefits − Bottom 20–30%, other replacement income − Bottom 20–30%, Collective services
From
Result
€77.1 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d3-deferred-shared-out: Bottom 20–30%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out, €77.1bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d3-deferred-shared-out.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, paid a month per person

€740EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 20–30%, levies paid × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€740

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d3-pp: Bottom 20–30%, paid a month per person, €740 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d3-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, levies paid

€61bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 20–30%, Taxes on products + Bottom 20–30%, Taxes on production + Bottom 20–30%, Corporate tax + Bottom 20–30%, CSG on earnings and benefits + Bottom 20–30%, CSG on capital income + Bottom 20–30%, Income tax + Bottom 20–30%, Other taxes on income and wealth + Bottom 20–30%, Pension contributions + Bottom 20–30%, Other contributions
From
Result
€61.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d3: Bottom 20–30%, levies paid, €61bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30%, CSG

€6.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The generalised social contribution, levied on earnings, benefits and capital income.

Calculation

Computed as
CSG × Bottom 20–30%, CSG ÷ All groups, CSG
From
Result
€6.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-csg-d3: Bottom 20–30%, CSG, €6.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-csg-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Living standard at D3, constant 2024 euros

€20,610Estimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Disposable income per consumption unit a year at the threshold, in constant 2024 euros: what one person living alone has to spend; metropolitan France, survey on tax and social incomes.
Caveat
Insee's distributional accounts rank people by a survey-based living standard close to, but not the same as, this one.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Distribution des niveaux de vie, données annuelles de 1996 à 2024
Where
Sheet “Données”, row 7 “3e décile (D3)”, column AF (2023), en euros 2024 constants; raw/reve-niv-vie-decile-individu.xlsx
Published
2026
As published
€20,610
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-living-2023-d3: Living standard at D3, constant 2024 euros, €20,610 (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-living-2023-d3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, net financial income, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data

€50EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, Net financial income × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€50

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-capital-financial-d4-pp: Bottom 30–40%, net financial income, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data, €50 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-capital-financial-d4-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, Subsidies on products

€3.1bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Subsidies paid per unit sold, public transport above all, attributed to the households who consume.

Calculation

Computed as
Subsidies on products × Bottom 30–40%, Subsidies on products ÷ All groups, Subsidies on products
From
Result
€3.1 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-subsidies_products-d4: Bottom 30–40%, Subsidies on products, €3.1bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-subsidies_products-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, received a month per person, collective services by income

€1,660EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, transfers received, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,660

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d4-pp-by-income: Bottom 30–40%, received a month per person, collective services by income, €1,660 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d4-pp-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay

€99.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Replacement income counts as deferred pay, as in Insee's box: pensions, unemployment benefits and the other replacement income (sick pay and work-injury annuities), Insee's rows 31 to 33, are left out.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, transfers received − Bottom 30–40%, Pensions − Bottom 30–40%, Unemployment benefits − Bottom 30–40%, other replacement income
From
Result
€99.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d4-deferred: Bottom 30–40%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, €99.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d4-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income

€1,130EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,130

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d4-pp-deferred-by-income: Bottom 30–40%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income, €1,130 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d4-pp-deferred-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out

€920EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€920

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d4-pp-deferred-shared-out: Bottom 30–40%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out, €920 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d4-pp-deferred-shared-out.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, levies paid

€77.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, Taxes on products + Bottom 30–40%, Taxes on production + Bottom 30–40%, Corporate tax + Bottom 30–40%, CSG on earnings and benefits + Bottom 30–40%, CSG on capital income + Bottom 30–40%, Income tax + Bottom 30–40%, Other taxes on income and wealth + Bottom 30–40%, Pension contributions + Bottom 30–40%, Other contributions
From
Result
€77.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d4: Bottom 30–40%, levies paid, €77.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, CSG

€9.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The generalised social contribution, levied on earnings, benefits and capital income.

Calculation

Computed as
CSG × Bottom 30–40%, CSG ÷ All groups, CSG
From
Result
€9.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-csg-d4: Bottom 30–40%, CSG, €9.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-csg-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, share of the CSG on capital income

4.8%EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's part of the CSG on capital income: of the CSG on investment income, its share of net financial income; of the CSG on property income, its share of rents, actual and imputed (an allocation scenario).
Caveat
An allocation scenario: Insee attributes the whole CSG to each group but does not split it by base, and no source found gives the bases of the CSG on capital income by group. The CSG on investment income (interest, dividends, life insurance) is shared as Insee's net financial income. The CSG on property income is levied on rents landlords receive, capital gains and annuities; Insee's only row near it adds owner-occupiers' imputed rents, which pay no CSG, and holds no capital gains, so sharing it as that row is a convention. The alternatives share all of it as net financial income, or as the group's whole capital income.

Calculation

Computed as
(CSG on income from investments, 2023 × Bottom 30–40%, Net financial income ÷ All groups, Net financial income + CSG on income from property, 2023 × Bottom 30–40%, Rents, actual and imputed ÷ All groups, Rents, actual and imputed) ÷ (CSG on income from investments, 2023 + CSG on income from property, 2023) × 100
From
Result
4.8%

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-csg-key-d4: Bottom 30–40%, share of the CSG on capital income, 4.8% (2023), calculated by this site from Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-csg-key-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, paid a month per person, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€890EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, levies paid, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€890

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d4-pp-cofog: Bottom 30–40%, paid a month per person, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €890 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d4-pp-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, unemployment contributions

€2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's unemployment contributions, Insee's row 27, grown by households' contributions after 2023.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, Unemployment contributions
From
Result
€2.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-contrib_unemployment-d4: Bottom 30–40%, unemployment contributions, €2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-contrib_unemployment-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, Unemployment contributions

€2bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
Employer and employee contributions to unemployment insurance, Insee's row 27.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 27 “Cotisations sociales chômage1”, columns I and J (V7 + V8), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 27, V7: -0.9; row 27, V8: -1.1
As published
€2.0 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-contrib_unemployment-d4: Bottom 30–40%, Unemployment contributions, €2bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-contrib_unemployment-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, profits kept in companies, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data

€20EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, Profits kept in companies × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€20

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-capital-retained-d5-pp: Bottom 40–50%, profits kept in companies, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data, €20 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-capital-retained-d5-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, transfers received

€133.1bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 40–50%, Subsidies on production + Bottom 40–50%, Pensions + Bottom 40–50%, Unemployment benefits + Bottom 40–50%, Other cash benefits + Bottom 40–50%, Health care + Bottom 40–50%, Education + Bottom 40–50%, Social care and housing aid + Bottom 40–50%, Culture and leisure + Bottom 40–50%, Collective services
From
Result
€133.1 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d5: Bottom 40–50%, transfers received, €133.1bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, received a month per person, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€1,750EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,750

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d5-pp-cofog: Bottom 40–50%, received a month per person, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €1,750 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d5-pp-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, received a month per person, collective services by income

€1,570EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, transfers received, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,570

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d5-pp-by-income: Bottom 40–50%, received a month per person, collective services by income, €1,570 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d5-pp-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, transfers received, collective services by income

€128.9bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Collective services, Insee's row 46, are shared in proportion to income after levies and cash benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, transfers received − Bottom 40–50%, Collective services + Bottom 40–50%, collective services by income
From
Result
€128.9 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d5-by-income: Bottom 40–50%, transfers received, collective services by income, €128.9bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d5-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay

€1,050EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay × 10⁹ ÷ Bottom 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,050

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d5-pp-deferred: Bottom 40–50%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, €1,050 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d5-pp-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, other replacement income

€3.1bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's sick pay and work-injury annuities, Insee's row 33, grown by households' cash benefits after 2023.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, Other replacement income
From
Result
€3.1 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-replacement-d5: Bottom 40–50%, other replacement income, €3.1bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-replacement-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, Pension contributions

€24.9bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Employer and employee contributions to pension schemes, imputed contributions and firms' collective schemes included.

Calculation

Computed as
Pension contributions × Bottom 40–50%, Pension contributions ÷ All groups, Pension contributions
From
Result
€24.9 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-contrib_pensions-d5: Bottom 40–50%, Pension contributions, €24.9bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-contrib_pensions-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50%, levies paid, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€86.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies, under the conventions its label names. Each of Insee's 2023 items of the group is scaled to Eurostat's total of its category for the year, S13 receipts for levies and COFOG total expenditure for spending, as this site computed every year before October 2026: total expenditure holds investment and capital transfers that no household receives in the year.

Calculation

Computed as
Σ over Insee's items of the group's 2023 amount × the category's Eurostat total for the year ÷ Insee's items of the category, all groups
From
Result
€86.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d5-cofog: Bottom 40–50%, levies paid, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €86.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d5-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Profits kept in companies

€2.3bnEstimated2023

Definition

What it counts
The part of companies' profits that is not paid out, attributed to the households that own them.

Where it comes from

Source
Insee, Revenus des ménages élargis à l'ensemble de l'économie en 2023 (Insee Analyses n° 118)
Where
Sheet “Tableau complémentaire”, row 10 “Profits des entreprises non distribués aux ménages (B)”, columns M and N (V11 + V12), summed, signs dropped
Published
16 April 2026
It says
row 10, V11: 1; row 10, V12: 1.3
As published
€2.3 billion
Read
2026-10-14

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-insee-2023-retained-d6: Top 40–50%, Profits kept in companies, €2.3bn (2023), from Insee (2026), Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-insee-2023-retained-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, received a month per person

€1,660EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 40–50%, transfers received × 10⁹ ÷ Top 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,660

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d6-pp: Top 40–50%, received a month per person, €1,660 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d6-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Subsidies on production

€3.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Apprenticeship hiring aid, sector aid and other subsidies to producers, attributed to households.

Calculation

Computed as
Subsidies on production × Top 40–50%, Subsidies on production ÷ All groups, Subsidies on production
From
Result
€3.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-subsidies_production-d6: Top 40–50%, Subsidies on production, €3.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-subsidies_production-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Pensions

€43.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Retirement pensions, survivors' pensions included.

Calculation

Computed as
Pensions × Top 40–50%, Pensions ÷ All groups, Pensions
From
Result
€43.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-pensions-d6: Top 40–50%, Pensions, €43.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-pensions-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Unemployment benefits

€3.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Unemployment insurance and solidarity benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
Unemployment benefits × Top 40–50%, Unemployment benefits ÷ All groups, Unemployment benefits
From
Result
€3.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-unemployment_benefits-d6: Top 40–50%, Unemployment benefits, €3.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-unemployment_benefits-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Education

€11.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Schooling from nursery to university, school transport included, received in kind.

Calculation

Computed as
Education × Top 40–50%, Education ÷ All groups, Education
From
Result
€11.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-education-d6: Top 40–50%, Education, €11.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-education-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€147.1bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Each of Insee's 2023 items of the group is scaled to Eurostat's total of its category for the year, S13 receipts for levies and COFOG total expenditure for spending, as this site computed every year before October 2026: total expenditure holds investment and capital transfers that no household receives in the year.

Calculation

Computed as
Σ over Insee's items of the group's 2023 amount × the category's Eurostat total for the year ÷ Insee's items of the category, all groups
From
Result
€147.1 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d6-cofog: Top 40–50%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €147.1bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d6-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out

€760EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 40–50%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out × 10⁹ ÷ Top 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€760

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d6-pp-deferred-shared-out: Top 40–50%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out, €760 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d6-pp-deferred-shared-out.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, Taxes on products

€32bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
VAT, energy and other excise duties and property transfer duties, collected by firms on what they sell; Insee attributes them to the households who consume.

Calculation

Computed as
Taxes on products × Top 40–50%, Taxes on products ÷ All groups, Taxes on products
From
Result
€32.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-taxes_products-d6: Top 40–50%, Taxes on products, €32bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-taxes_products-d6.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, paid a month per person, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€1,230EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 40–50%, levies paid, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category × 10⁹ ÷ Top 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,230

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d6-pp-cofog: Top 40–50%, paid a month per person, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €1,230 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d6-pp-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 40–50%, paid a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay

€920EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 40–50%, levies paid, replacement income as deferred pay × 10⁹ ÷ Top 40–50%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€920

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d6-pp-deferred: Top 40–50%, paid a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, €920 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d6-pp-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Living standard at D6, constant 2024 euros, a month

€2,440EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The yearly amount divided by twelve, rounded to ten euros.

Calculation

Computed as
Living standard at D6, constant 2024 euros ÷ 12, rounded to €10
From
Result
€2,440

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-living-2023-d6-month: Living standard at D6, constant 2024 euros, a month, €2,440 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-living-2023-d6-month.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, Health care

€21.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Care paid for by public health insurance and hospitals, received in kind.

Calculation

Computed as
Health care × Top 30–40%, Health care ÷ All groups, Health care
From
Result
€21.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-health-d7: Top 30–40%, Health care, €21.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-health-d7.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, received a month per person, collective services by income

€1,670EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 30–40%, transfers received, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Top 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,670

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d7-pp-by-income: Top 30–40%, received a month per person, collective services by income, €1,670 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d7-pp-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income

€1,030EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 30–40%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Top 30–40%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,030

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d7-pp-deferred-by-income: Top 30–40%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income, €1,030 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d7-pp-deferred-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, Taxes on production

€13.7bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Payroll taxes, business property tax and other taxes firms pay for producing, attributed to households.

Calculation

Computed as
Taxes on production × Top 30–40%, Taxes on production ÷ All groups, Taxes on production
From
Result
€13.7 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-taxes_production-d7: Top 30–40%, Taxes on production, €13.7bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-taxes_production-d7.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, CSG on capital income

€1.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The part of the CSG levied on capital income: interest, dividends, life insurance, rents and capital gains.
Competing figures
  • €929m, the CSG on capital income by financial income alone. The same computation with another key for the CSG on capital income.
  • €1.1bn, the CSG on capital income by all capital income. The same computation with another key for the CSG on capital income.
Caveat
An allocation scenario: Insee attributes the whole CSG to each group but does not split it by base, and no source found gives the bases of the CSG on capital income by group. The CSG on investment income (interest, dividends, life insurance) is shared as Insee's net financial income. The CSG on property income is levied on rents landlords receive, capital gains and annuities; Insee's only row near it adds owner-occupiers' imputed rents, which pay no CSG, and holds no capital gains, so sharing it as that row is a convention. The alternatives share all of it as net financial income, or as the group's whole capital income.

Calculation

Computed as
CSG on capital income × Top 30–40%, share of the CSG on capital income ÷ 100
From
Result
€1.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-csg_capital-d7: Top 30–40%, CSG on capital income, €1.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-csg_capital-d7.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, Other contributions

€21.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Employer and employee contributions to health, disability, work-injury, unemployment and family insurance.

Calculation

Computed as
Other contributions × Top 30–40%, Other contributions ÷ All groups, Other contributions
From
Result
€21.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-contrib_others-d7: Top 30–40%, Other contributions, €21.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-contrib_others-d7.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 30–40%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out

€126.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies, under the conventions its label names. The part of corporate tax borne by the owners of French companies abroad, in proportion to the equity they hold, and the part of taxes on products visitors pay, in proportion to their consumption, are taken out; Insee holds both negligible.
Caveat
Insee attributes the whole amount to residents; the part falling outside France is taken out of every group in proportion.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 30–40%, levies paid − Top 30–40%, Corporate tax × Share of French companies' equity held outside France ÷ 100 − Top 30–40%, Taxes on products × Share of consumption by visitors ÷ 100
From
Result
€126.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d7-outside: Top 30–40%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out, €126.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d7-outside.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, net financial income, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data

€130EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, Net financial income × 10⁹ ÷ Top 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€130

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-capital-financial-d8-pp: Top 20–30%, net financial income, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data, €130 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-capital-financial-d8-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, profits kept in companies, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data

€60EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, Profits kept in companies × 10⁹ ÷ Top 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€60

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-capital-retained-d8-pp: Top 20–30%, profits kept in companies, monthly equivalent per resident, 2023 data, €60 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-capital-retained-d8-pp.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Subsidies on production

€4.8bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Apprenticeship hiring aid, sector aid and other subsidies to producers, attributed to households.

Calculation

Computed as
Subsidies on production × Top 20–30%, Subsidies on production ÷ All groups, Subsidies on production
From
Result
€4.8 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-subsidies_production-d8: Top 20–30%, Subsidies on production, €4.8bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-subsidies_production-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Pensions

€47.8bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Retirement pensions, survivors' pensions included.

Calculation

Computed as
Pensions × Top 20–30%, Pensions ÷ All groups, Pensions
From
Result
€47.8 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-pensions-d8: Top 20–30%, Pensions, €47.8bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-pensions-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Other cash benefits

€11.9bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Sick pay and work-injury benefits, family benefits, minimum incomes, disability benefits, and the reimbursements of firms' group health insurance, which Insee counts among cash benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
Other cash benefits × Top 20–30%, Other cash benefits ÷ All groups, Other cash benefits
From
Result
€11.9 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-other_cash-d8: Top 20–30%, Other cash benefits, €11.9bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-other_cash-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay

€76.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Replacement income counts as deferred pay, as in Insee's box: pensions, unemployment benefits and the other replacement income (sick pay and work-injury annuities), Insee's rows 31 to 33, are left out.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, transfers received − Top 20–30%, Pensions − Top 20–30%, Unemployment benefits − Top 20–30%, other replacement income
From
Result
€76.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d8-deferred: Top 20–30%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, €76.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d8-deferred.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out

€650EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out × 10⁹ ÷ Top 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€650

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d8-pp-deferred-shared-out: Top 20–30%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services left out, €650 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d8-pp-deferred-shared-out.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, levies paid

€157.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, Taxes on products + Top 20–30%, Taxes on production + Top 20–30%, Corporate tax + Top 20–30%, CSG on earnings and benefits + Top 20–30%, CSG on capital income + Top 20–30%, Income tax + Top 20–30%, Other taxes on income and wealth + Top 20–30%, Pension contributions + Top 20–30%, Other contributions
From
Result
€157.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d8: Top 20–30%, levies paid, €157.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Taxes on production

€16.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Payroll taxes, business property tax and other taxes firms pay for producing, attributed to households.

Calculation

Computed as
Taxes on production × Top 20–30%, Taxes on production ÷ All groups, Taxes on production
From
Result
€16.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-taxes_production-d8: Top 20–30%, Taxes on production, €16.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-taxes_production-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, Other contributions

€27.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Employer and employee contributions to health, disability, work-injury, unemployment and family insurance.

Calculation

Computed as
Other contributions × Top 20–30%, Other contributions ÷ All groups, Other contributions
From
Result
€27.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-contrib_others-d8: Top 20–30%, Other contributions, €27.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-contrib_others-d8.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, paid a month per person, the part borne outside France taken out

€1,890EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out × 10⁹ ÷ Top 20–30%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,890

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d8-pp-outside: Top 20–30%, paid a month per person, the part borne outside France taken out, €1,890 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d8-pp-outside.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 20–30%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out

€155.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies, under the conventions its label names. The part of corporate tax borne by the owners of French companies abroad, in proportion to the equity they hold, and the part of taxes on products visitors pay, in proportion to their consumption, are taken out; Insee holds both negligible.
Caveat
Insee attributes the whole amount to residents; the part falling outside France is taken out of every group in proportion.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 20–30%, levies paid − Top 20–30%, Corporate tax × Share of French companies' equity held outside France ÷ 100 − Top 20–30%, Taxes on products × Share of consumption by visitors ÷ 100
From
Result
€155.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d8-outside: Top 20–30%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out, €155.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d8-outside.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, Unemployment benefits

€3.7bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Unemployment insurance and solidarity benefits.

Calculation

Computed as
Unemployment benefits × Top 10–20%, Unemployment benefits ÷ All groups, Unemployment benefits
From
Result
€3.7 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-unemployment_benefits-d9: Top 10–20%, Unemployment benefits, €3.7bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-unemployment_benefits-d9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, Social care and housing aid

€6.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Care for dependent elderly and disabled people, childcare and other social action, housing benefits and the energy cheque, and the running costs of social security, received in kind.

Calculation

Computed as
Social care and housing aid × Top 10–20%, Social care and housing aid ÷ All groups, Social care and housing aid
From
Result
€6.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-other_in_kind-d9: Top 10–20%, Social care and housing aid, €6.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-other_in_kind-d9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€152.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every transfer attributed to the group, subsidies included, under the conventions its label names. Each of Insee's 2023 items of the group is scaled to Eurostat's total of its category for the year, S13 receipts for levies and COFOG total expenditure for spending, as this site computed every year before October 2026: total expenditure holds investment and capital transfers that no household receives in the year.

Calculation

Computed as
Σ over Insee's items of the group's 2023 amount × the category's Eurostat total for the year ÷ Insee's items of the category, all groups
From
Result
€152.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-got-d9-cofog: Top 10–20%, transfers received, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €152.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-got-d9-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, Income tax

€16.1bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Personal income tax, net of refundable credits.

Calculation

Computed as
Income tax × Top 10–20%, Income tax ÷ All groups, Income tax
From
Result
€16.1 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-income_tax-d9: Top 10–20%, Income tax, €16.1bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-income_tax-d9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, Other taxes on income and wealth

€3.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Residence tax, the wealth tax on property (IFI), CRDS and other taxes on income and wealth.

Calculation

Computed as
Other taxes on income and wealth × Top 10–20%, Other taxes on income and wealth ÷ All groups, Other taxes on income and wealth
From
Result
€3.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-other_income_taxes-d9: Top 10–20%, Other taxes on income and wealth, €3.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-other_income_taxes-d9.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, levies paid, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category

€188.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies, under the conventions its label names. Each of Insee's 2023 items of the group is scaled to Eurostat's total of its category for the year, S13 receipts for levies and COFOG total expenditure for spending, as this site computed every year before October 2026: total expenditure holds investment and capital transfers that no household receives in the year.

Calculation

Computed as
Σ over Insee's items of the group's 2023 amount × the category's Eurostat total for the year ÷ Insee's items of the category, all groups
From
Result
€188.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d9-cofog: Top 10–20%, levies paid, Insee's items scaled to Eurostat's totals by category, €188.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d9-cofog.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10–20%, paid a month per person, the part borne outside France taken out

€2,410EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 10–20%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out × 10⁹ ÷ Top 10–20%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€2,410

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-p-d9-pp-outside: Top 10–20%, paid a month per person, the part borne outside France taken out, €2,410 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-p-d9-pp-outside.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income

€1,500EstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The group's amount over its people, a month per person.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 10%, transfers received, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income × 10⁹ ÷ Top 10%, people ÷ 12
From
Result
€1,500

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-r-d10-pp-deferred-by-income: Top 10%, received a month per person, replacement income as deferred pay, collective services by income, €1,500 (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-r-d10-pp-deferred-by-income.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Top 10%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out

€423.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Every levy attributed to the group, gross of subsidies, under the conventions its label names. The part of corporate tax borne by the owners of French companies abroad, in proportion to the equity they hold, and the part of taxes on products visitors pay, in proportion to their consumption, are taken out; Insee holds both negligible.
Caveat
Insee attributes the whole amount to residents; the part falling outside France is taken out of every group in proportion.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 10%, levies paid − Top 10%, Corporate tax × Share of French companies' equity held outside France ÷ 100 − Top 10%, Taxes on products × Share of consumption by visitors ÷ 100
From
Result
€423.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-paid-d10-outside: Top 10%, levies paid, the part borne outside France taken out, €423.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-paid-d10-outside.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Lenders outside France

€158.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The part of borrowing lent by non-residents.

Calculation

Computed as
Borrowing × Share of net borrowing from abroad ÷ 100
From
Result
€158.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-bw-abroad: Lenders outside France, €158.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-bw-abroad.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

General government

€1,824bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Everything general government receives: the levies Insee attributes to people, other revenue, borrowing and transfers from abroad, and what passes through the schemes outside general government that Insee counts: the benefits they pay come in, the contributions they receive go out.

Calculation

Computed as
Taxes on products + Taxes on production + Corporate tax + CSG on earnings and benefits + CSG on capital income + Income tax + Other taxes on income and wealth + Pension contributions + Other contributions + Lenders in France + Other revenue + Inheritance and gift duties + Benefits from other schemes + Lenders outside France + International cooperation from the EU + Capital transfers from the EU (recovery plan)
From
Result
€1,823.9 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-gov: General government, €1,824bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-gov.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Repaid to the Banque de France

€7bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Public debt this holder let mature or sold, net, over the year: general government repaid it with new borrowing.

Calculation

Computed as
Borrowing × −Share of net borrowing from the Banque de France ÷ 100
From
Result
€7.0 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-bw-bdf: Repaid to the Banque de France, €7bn (2023), calculated by this site from Eurostat, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-bw-bdf.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10–20%, levies through companies

€25.8bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Taxes on products and on production and corporate tax that companies hand over but whose incidence Insee attributes to the group.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10–20%, Taxes on products + Bottom 10–20%, Taxes on production + Bottom 10–20%, Corporate tax
From
Result
€25.8 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-via-d2: Bottom 10–20%, levies through companies, €25.8bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-via-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 10%, subsidies through companies

€3.3bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Subsidies paid to companies whose benefit Insee attributes to the group.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 10%, Subsidies on production
From
Result
€3.3 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-sub-d1: Bottom 10%, subsidies through companies, €3.3bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-sub-d1.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 30–40%, subsidies through companies

€5.4bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
Subsidies paid to companies whose benefit Insee attributes to the group.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 30–40%, Subsidies on products + Bottom 30–40%, Subsidies on production
From
Result
€5.4 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-sub-d4: Bottom 30–40%, subsidies through companies, €5.4bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-sub-d4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Subsidies, 2023

€70.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Subsidies on products + Subsidies on production
From
Result
€70.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-subsidies: Subsidies, 2023, €70.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-subsidies.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Cash benefits, 2023

€591.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Pensions + Unemployment benefits + Other cash benefits
From
Result
€591.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-4: Cash benefits, 2023, €591.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 20–30% → Taxes on income and wealth, 2023

€6.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 20–30%, CSG on earnings and benefits + Bottom 20–30%, Income tax + Bottom 20–30%, Other taxes on income and wealth
From
Result
€6.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-p-d3-l-kind-3: Bottom 20–30% → Taxes on income and wealth, 2023, €6.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-p-d3-l-kind-3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Bottom 40–50% → Taxes on income and wealth, 2023

€12.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, CSG on earnings and benefits + Bottom 40–50%, Income tax + Bottom 40–50%, Other taxes on income and wealth
From
Result
€12.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-p-d5-l-kind-3: Bottom 40–50% → Taxes on income and wealth, 2023, €12.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-p-d5-l-kind-3.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Taxes on products and production → General government, 2023

€446.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Taxes on products + Taxes on production
From
Result
€446.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-l-kind-2-gov: Taxes on products and production → General government, 2023, €446.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-l-kind-2-gov.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Taxes on income and wealth → General government, 2023

€256.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
CSG on earnings and benefits + Income tax + Other taxes on income and wealth
From
Result
€256.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-l-kind-3-gov: Taxes on income and wealth → General government, 2023, €256.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Commission des comptes de la Sécurité sociale, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-l-kind-3-gov.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

General government → Cash benefits, 2023

€591.2bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Pensions + Unemployment benefits + Other cash benefits
From
Result
€591.2 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-gov-t-kind-4: General government → Cash benefits, 2023, €591.2bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-gov-t-kind-4.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Cash benefits → Bottom 10–20%, 2023

€49.5bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 10–20%, Pensions + Bottom 10–20%, Unemployment benefits + Bottom 10–20%, Other cash benefits
From
Result
€49.5 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-4-r-d2: Cash benefits → Bottom 10–20%, 2023, €49.5bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-4-r-d2.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Cash benefits → Bottom 40–50%, 2023

€56.6bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Bottom 40–50%, Pensions + Bottom 40–50%, Unemployment benefits + Bottom 40–50%, Other cash benefits
From
Result
€56.6 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-4-r-d5: Cash benefits → Bottom 40–50%, 2023, €56.6bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-4-r-d5.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.

Why believe this?

Transfers in kind → Top 30–40%, 2023

€45.9bnEstimatedCalculated by this site2023

Definition

What it counts
The sum of the levies or transfers of one kind that the detailed diagram shows one by one.

Calculation

Computed as
Top 30–40%, Health care + Top 30–40%, Education + Top 30–40%, Social care and housing aid + Top 30–40%, Culture and leisure
From
Result
€45.9 billion

Cite this figure: Gazagnaire, T., How France works, version unreleased-ef7a7ba2, figure dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-5-r-d7: Transfers in kind → Top 30–40%, 2023, €45.9bn (2023), calculated by this site from Insee, Licence Ouverte 2.0, https://patte-blanche.org/c/dna-2023-tenths-kind-t-kind-5-r-d7.html, accessed on 2026-11-12. Permanent link.